Close Topic Suggestion - Topic

Member

Posts: 38,306

Joined: Nov 22 2006

Gold: 166.92

Feb 19 2008 09:36pm

Quote (paparick @ Tue, Feb 19 2008, 10:34pm)

i do NOT need nor do i want useless comments appended to my posts.

and a 'vouch' is the most useless of all posts. As a matter of fact it is a direct indicator of the usefulness of the poster.

Any more and out comes my big stick

ouched by paparicks hammer O.o

It can be abused easily, sorry to say.
If they close there thread, and remake in 1 hour..
They just dodged the 4 hour bump timer.

I'm going to null this.

fhmfhm

Member

Posts: 10,262

Joined: Apr 28 2007

Gold: 0.00

#12

Feb 19 2008 10:11pm

Wow, a great idea!

[X] Yes

Oscar.

Retired Moderator

Posts: 19,061

Joined: Apr 30 2004

Gold: 148.30

Trader: Trusted

#13

Feb 19 2008 10:13pm

Quote (paparick @ Wed, 20 Feb 2008, 05:34)

I guess if someone posted "I agree with that" it would be kinda the same?

I agree with your post up.

hedonism

Member

Posts: 33,156

Joined: Apr 8 2006

Gold: 737.50

#14

Feb 19 2008 10:15pm

http://forums.d2jsp.org/index.php?showtopic=4133245&f=258 <- suggested by me a year and a half ago

yes from me

This post was edited by hedonism on Feb 19 2008 10:17pm

sew

Retired Moderator

Posts: 15,413

Joined: Jan 19 2007

Gold: 11.66

Trader: Trusted

#15

Feb 19 2008 10:17pm

Sounds nice to me

fire_up14

Member

Posts: 19,714

Joined: Aug 5 2007

Gold: 0.00

#16

Feb 19 2008 10:19pm

Quote (paparick @ Wed, Feb 20 2008, 03:19am)

i don't see how it can be abused unless the originator intends to close his topic and post another one right afterwards.

this could be prevented by having a 1-hour repost limit as is already in effect.

sounds like a good idea

I agree.

Darkro

Member

Posts: 8,617

Joined: Dec 30 2005

Gold: 2,735.00

Trader: Trusted

#17

Feb 19 2008 10:19pm

Very nice idea, well thought of to. My anwser would have to be yes.

staticHL

Member

Posts: 5,242

Joined: Mar 19 2007

Gold: 8,660.00

#18

Feb 20 2008 12:06am

i think the topic creater himself should be able to close his topics... that makes a lot less work for mods and has the same effect only more efficiant.

i vote no based on the fact mods will be overwhelmed with topics to be closed

This post was edited by staticHL on Feb 20 2008 12:07am

JayEm

Member

Posts: 23,775

Joined: Jan 26 2006

Gold: 1,333.38

#19

Feb 20 2008 08:13am

Quote (staticHL @ Wed, Feb 20 2008, 06:06am)

they have that anyway with useless spam in the forums anyway..

think about it mate..

happyguy44

Banned

Posts: 5,174

Joined: Jun 29 2007

Gold: 811.25

Warn: 10%

#20

Feb 20 2008 08:17am

why not instead add a close your own thread button however if you use this your still not supost to repost until 4 hours are up.

Go Back To Site Suggestions Archive Topic List