Well, it was earlier discussed in the GH that stars above the 25-50$ donation (blue star) are confidential.

Soo, we aren't allowed to ask about them; our threads will get closed. However, it came to my attention that it doesn't state anywhere in the rules not ask about it or that you aren't allowed to tell anyone etc.

So. How about we add that rule:

You may not discuss the price of any donor star that is listed as Confidential:





Suggestions as to changing what the rule says, but keeping it the same basic rule, are greatly appreciated

Voted No.
Its up to the person to discuss how much they spent Imo.

Besides, anyone who asks, is going to ask for their own benefit, not to make fun of others for spending that much.

if i'm not mistaken, you already CAN get in trouble for disclosing the price of the higher stars.

Yea, but if they DO ask, and the person who was asked reports that to a mod, they can get in some big trouble (not sure if they can be warned or not on a first offence), and there's no rule stating that.



You can, but there's no real rule in the Forum rules stating that you can

Quote (cheeseballl @ Tue, Jan 6 2009, 01:05pm)

You can, but there's no real rule in the Forum rules stating that you can

a mod isnt going to punish you for disclosing 1 or two prices about your own star.

If you provided that full list of all the prices though, i would expect anyone to get in trouble.

i think it's understood that confidential means you don't tell others about it?

Voted no, why would you even care?

confidential is kinda obvious that you shouldn't talk about it, but sure i guess.. for the slow kids.

This post was edited by ImoK on Jan 6 2009 12:31pm

http://forums.d2jsp.org/index.php?showtopic=27054400&f=34

And yet they still ask. Maybe if there was a rule, it might reduce these kinds of threads

There are so many things that can get you banned/warned which are nowhere in the rules... i guess njaguar assumes that most people have the same standards as him about what's right and what not