i think he is just playing dumb now. no one can be this stupid.

if I don't post back in my topic to state the item is gone, I will keep having notifications in the next 4 hrs from someone to keep offering in my topic.

Yes no one is stupid, what I am doing here is stating that the function of "t4t" or "pmed" should not be treated as "early bump"

Posts 12 and 13 should have been 1 post not 2.

Other than that i don't think theres a problem replying directly to a post.

You can edit your most recent post, and if it's too late, then you can reply after the first guy who writes "bin" in your 20 Shako example, without waiting 4h. Questions?

then you edit your first post. and if you can't edit anymore you make a new topic if you REALLY need to edit your topic for every item sold.
or you could just state you are out of stock even though it is against the rules if you do it 4hours before your last reply no one going to report you for that.

if you want to make a site suggestion post here: https://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=258
GL

Your thread was just excessive early bumping. that's why you got reported.

You cannot be this stupid.

Clearly an early bump it is what it is. Get over it and move on.

Early bump all you want too btw they only ever seem to close threads for it. Really doesn't affect you that much. Just don't get surprised if they sometimes get closed.

Also if your thread gets to the point where you need to edit it and you no longer can do so. Don't bump that dead thread, just make a new one.

Just make new topic. Who buys shakos from a 3 day old topic anyway, esp when you can't edit the price in op to reflect current market conditions.

Or just edit the very last post instead of bumping every 2 min.

This has already been pointed out to you like 5 times in this thread.

He knows he is breaking the rule. But it is a rule many people break and hardly enforced. I see offers and counter-offers in quick succession all the time and the post was not closed because it facilitated trading. The way I see it, some moderator somewhere is power-tripping. This is like catching someone in posession of a beer can in the car visible through the window. Sure you have the right to arrest because of some obscure law somewhere, but that police is still an asshole to do so.

which means I can reply "t4t no more left" within 4hrs to the guy who writes "bin", but only after I can't edit my topic anymore

what is the difference?