To be fair nearly all your replies are in the same minute or within 1 minute of the original post so your not really gaining much benefit from all these "early bumps".

Someone got butt hurt for some reason and reported.

Replying is better than opening 5/6 different ft topics for the same item, which is common enough aswell.

threads move fast. after 1minute your thread is probably already out of top100 threads. so yeah it's just early bumping.
i already provided the rules and threads with examples. doesn't matter if anyone thinks the rule is dumb or w/e it's the rule. deal with it. if you early bump and someone reports you your thread gets closed.

Crystal clear rule that is detrimental to a trading post. The rule needs to change.

A T4T post is not just a thank you note. It is an announcement that the item is no longer available.

Also if you’re not happy with an offer, you should have the ability to counter-offer right away. A one-to-one reply to a potential buyer is not a spam.

Post 12 and 13 are back to back replies from you. It violates the rule.

This post was edited by Ashirgo on Feb 22 2023 09:26am

I make an example

I have 20 shakos to trade in the topic, and after 3 days I can't edit my topic anymore.

Now one person makes an offer and trade, after the trade can I reply saying how many are left in my topic to show other people, in case many other people keep offering in my topic but I have nothing left

so is my reply after this trade within 4 hrs marked as early bump? or I need to keep silent and watching many people keep offering in my topic

fully agree with you

Do you understand the words "back to back reply"?

Dude, you cant have 2 posts one after another with less than 4h between them.
It is that simple

See, instead od making post #36 you could have edited post #35. But dont worry, i reported it as spam

This post was edited by Kratos7331 on Feb 22 2023 09:31am

I don't fully understand, as t4t is not back to back, as it did help inform someone about any item just got traded out and is no more available. do not waste time making more offers for it

You can only post in your own thread once every 4 hours otherwise it is considered early bumping/spam, hope this helps. You posted in your thread 14 times in less then 4 hours.