d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Archives > Softcore USWest 2010 > Iso: Brigadier > Your Sc Poofed
Prev123456Next
Add Reply New Topic
Member
Posts: 34,362
Joined: Feb 8 2009
Gold: 0.00
Nov 29 2010 10:10pm
Quote (Wakeskater77 @ Nov 30 2010 04:08am)
I think the fact that it didn't poof on him is a moot point

I think the fact that he sold him a (potentially) unperm sc is the problem.

It's not like it became unperm when this kid sold it to the other kid.

Brigadier still sold this kid a (potentially) unperm sc...and therefore should refund him...if it did indeed poof


I personally would

depending on The time between 2nd owner and sell to 3rd owner

and the Rep / if i know 3rd owner

otherwise i wouldnt...
Member
Posts: 383
Joined: Nov 16 2010
Gold: 0.73
Nov 29 2010 10:12pm
If He never stated if it was perm or unperm then it would be shawnyboys fualt for not asking if the sc was perm or not
Member
Posts: 52,256
Joined: Jul 10 2010
Gold: 110.20
Nov 29 2010 10:13pm
Quote (MgBrandon @ Nov 29 2010 09:12pm)
If He never stated if it was perm or unperm then it would be shawnyboys fualt for not asking if the sc was perm or not


Everything is assumed perm or legit if not stated unperm.
Member
Posts: 31,837
Joined: Sep 29 2005
Gold: 0.00
Nov 29 2010 10:13pm
Quote (Associate @ Nov 29 2010 10:10pm)
I personally would

depending on The time between 2nd owner and sell to 3rd owner

and the Rep / if i know 3rd owner

otherwise i wouldnt...


u sure ur not in politics?
Member
Posts: 26,027
Joined: Jan 14 2006
Gold: 110.00
Nov 29 2010 10:13pm
Quote (Associate @ Nov 29 2010 10:10pm)
I personally would

depending on The time between 2nd owner and sell to 3rd owner

and the Rep / if i know 3rd owner

otherwise i wouldnt...


I think a lot does depend on the third owner. Obviously if they're sketch...then probably not.

But if they're creditable, then it's obvious that Shawny was still sold an unperm sc at perm sc cost...and he should therefore be refunded by Brigadier

Also...the time limitation is also not really a consideration. I think if you sell a duped item to a creditable user who then sells it to another creditable user who has it poof on them a year or two down the road...I think you should still be on the hook for a repay at the original price.

It has more to do with the creditability of the chain of users than anything else.

Quote (MgBrandon @ Nov 29 2010 10:12pm)
If He never stated if it was perm or unperm then it would be shawnyboys fualt for not asking if the sc was perm or not


if you buy at perm price it's assumed perm

``

This post was edited by Wakeskater77 on Nov 29 2010 10:14pm
Member
Posts: 67,551
Joined: Feb 4 2010
Gold: 99,750.37
Nov 29 2010 10:13pm
Quote (Shawnyboy @ Nov 29 2010 07:58pm)
i bought a smiter pack from you which included a 20/5 sc.

i sold this sc for 90 fg. this sc has now poofed. wtf?

person was already refunded, but where does that leave me.


Who did you sell it to?
Member
Posts: 52,256
Joined: Jul 10 2010
Gold: 110.20
Nov 29 2010 10:20pm
Quote (Slowtoanger @ Nov 29 2010 09:13pm)
Who did you sell it to?


*To whom did you sell it?

wat
Member
Posts: 34,362
Joined: Feb 8 2009
Gold: 0.00
Nov 29 2010 10:21pm
Quote (bamatstar @ Nov 30 2010 04:13am)
u sure ur not in politics?


:P
Member
Posts: 51,780
Joined: Aug 9 2008
Gold: 0.69
Warn: 10%
Nov 29 2010 10:25pm
Quote (MgBrandon @ Nov 29 2010 09:12pm)
If He never stated if it was perm or unperm then it would be shawnyboys fualt for not asking if the sc was perm or not


Quote (FSW @ Nov 29 2010 09:13pm)
Everything is assumed perm or legit if not stated unperm.


This. X10
Member
Posts: 52,256
Joined: Jul 10 2010
Gold: 110.20
Nov 29 2010 10:26pm
Quote (Oldenglish800 @ Nov 29 2010 09:25pm)
This. X10


Quote (Matao @ Oct 14 2010 01:19am)
everything is deemed perm , unless stated otherwise
unless you said it was unperm ( which u  didnt ) , then you were selling as perm
so its actually you who fucked up
gl trying to sell anything on west kiddo


wat
Go Back To Softcore USWest 2010 Topic List
Prev123456Next
Add Reply New Topic