Lol before I knew about any tier lists or anything, when the game FIRST came out. I mained Fox, Falco, Sheik and Marth xD Top 4 in the game

melee far > brawl

nothing about this game is better only a few minor glitch fixes but they fucked the gameplay too hard for it to even matter. too much crap is going on. items are too overpowered, stages do random shit that interfears with the match and the match it self seems almost cartoonish.

graphics look like a bad woodie woodie pecker show and final smash is the gayest thing i have ever seen.

lets say we turn off items, and only use basic stages like final destenation... still the gameplay/ movement of the chars is too fucked/cartoonish.
game blows.

melee >


and more chars my fucking ass... half of brawls chars blow hard half of their moves are useless and had minimal thought put into them.
almost as if someone was saying "hurry the fuck up, this has to be on the shelf by next month"
horrible just horrible.

its only faster if you count that most of the stages fall apart (not a bad thing, just over done) and the fact that items can almost one hit you once you are 40% +

This post was edited by bear28 on Sep 8 2009 05:16pm

Are you a fuckin retard? :|
If you're gonna use the point of shitty items, and shitty stages then turn around and say you could just turn them off/not go on them, what the fuck was the point of even fucking mentioning it? And not every fucking move is useless you sack of fuck. I'm sick to fucking death of stupid random fucks like you bashing brawl because "bad items" or "bad stages" or it's "too slow". Give a real fucking reason.

even i looked at that post and went lolwut.

you say things look too cartoonish, but the characters in brawl aren't supposed to look real

See what I mean by these people and their retarded arguments? Yours atleast made sense -.-

id have to agree with you, stupid reasons

but, maybe some people like to use items? i dont but hey somebody might

lol some people arguing this will use anything for their cause. even though no one with any brains plays with items normally and such.

Sure, maybe they like items. Fair enough. But, why bash Brawl for it's items? IMO, it's item system is better than Melee's.

Anyway, threads like these aren't getting anywhere.

This post was edited by Ugg on Sep 8 2009 10:22pm

i like both games equal, because i generally play without items, and especially without final smashers.

I like brawl > melee. I use no items, and usually omit the random crap stages.