If you like Fire Emblem, and can freaking find Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance, get that.
(I still haven't been able to find it at gamestop and such, I could get it online.. but i like physically buying in person better >_>
Also maybe try the 2 Metroids, (3:Corruption, and The Other M)
Heard great things about Little Kings Story too, Muramasa: The Demon Blade I did enjoy quite a bit...
Oh and of course Super Mario Galaxy 1+2, they were gg, as well as New Super Mario Bros. (something along the lines of that, comes in a red case so its easy to spot)
and Mario Kart Wii, those are pretty much all the older (and a couple newer) ones I can think of...