Quote (stupidkid282 @ Tue, Jan 27 2009, 07:38pm)

Ok, you don't know how i play, you have never seen me play... THUS you cannot judge my playing cababilities.....If you cannot understand this simple logic, i feel sorry for you.

That's not "simple logic". That's your way of covering up the fact that you're a bad player.

You cannot have 2 tier lists...Again for the third time (do i really have to explain this again?) Tiers are just peoples opinions....the game was not created with lesser quality characters....

[b]Yes, explain it please, for you haven't explained it before. You just said some random shit. I meant 2 tier lists as in 1 previous tier list, then a new one recently came out.

1. A lot of characters play the same way (speed or strength, ect.

2. Any player can win by simply using smash attacks... Smash attacks are strong and are easy to juggle with.

Both of which, are extremely TRUE.......are you dumb? Mario, Luigi.....similiar characters, couple different moves.. Gannon, captain falc.....falco, wolf, fox...just examples...all similar characters, with a few different moves and characteristics....

WOW. Mario/Luigi juggle with tilts/aerials, no I'm not dumb. You're just throwing out random characters and the words "different moves" And since you were so desperate for "similar characters", you gave me the 3 star foxes. All of which have extremely different playstyles.

You're really not putting up any facts, just your opinion....

This is just pointless to say. You're doing the same.

Quote (stupidkid282 @ Tue, Jan 27 2009, 07:54pm)

Tell me this....how can you judge something you have never seen before? You continue to tell me i am "bad" but you have never seen me play.....

I read the tier lsit in brawl concerning the controversy..

pretty much says, tier lists are subject to change because people play different styles...

This defeats the purpose of a tier list. A tier list should be permanent, set in stone, and not subject to change...


all the chars i listed are very similar character wise, playing styles is all up to the actual player him or herself....SO, one can conclude that characters are similar.

Quote (charlesss @ Tue, Jan 27 2009, 08:01pm)

Ok there buddy.

Quote (Ugg @ Wed, Jan 28 2009, 02:57am)

You just contradticted yourself.
You're all over the fact about how everything is an opinion, now you're mad because the SBR decided it was time for a new tier list.
And no. Playstyles don't eliminate tier lists.
If it were Captain Falcon vs. MK, if the Captain Falcon decided he would use Falcon punch 593 times per stock because it was a unique playstyle, it does not mean the matchup between him and MK (might I add is 90:10) would change. You're partly right on your last sentence, except that one cannot conclude that characters are similar, it's playstyles that are similar. No character is near similar.

Quote (stupidkid282 @ Tue, Jan 27 2009, 08:26pm)

if people want to falcon punch 593 times per stock, let them do it.....Adapt and find another way to crush them...Don't blame the characters, the skill 90% the player not the character.