Yes, to a fanboy they might be the greatest of their generation. But being unique doesn't make them technical or mechanical masterpieces. Neither were the best game of their generation.

Agreed.
Shadow of the Collosus is a hot mess.

Huge open worlds with nothing in them and cringe worthy controls. But it's revered as Gods gift to man. Pretty much the definition of overrated.

Okay, this is purely your opinion. I said "one" of the greatest, there's many.
http://www.metacritic.com/game/playstation-2/shadow-of-the-colossus

Positive: 76 out of 77
Mixed: 1 out of 77
Negative: 0 out of 77

Unfortunately for you, most people (and critics) who have played the game, disagree. Making you a minority.

I don't know if I agree with you. You can objectively observe the quality of a game and objectively observe the ratings. I believe you can objectively come to the conclusion a game is over rated.

This post was edited by ROM on Dec 5 2016 05:29pm

He also thinks I'm calling them bad which I'm not. They're just overrated. SOTC isn't a 10 and it wasn't in the generation that it came out in either.

I get it you don't like the game, but this thread is about The Last Guardian, not your opinion of SoTC. I'm still pointing out that you are a minority in the category of people who have actually played the game.
5 more hours till the game launches

This post was edited by Bassist on Dec 5 2016 06:42pm

I know what this thread is for. Someone said he was waiting on reviews. I advised him the metacritic which is a very good score especially for a game that is coming out after long, tortured development.

He said he was hoping for better, I elaborated, you went off the deep end with your opinions.

Thanks.

You used your own opinion and called it elaborating?

Nah, I think Shadow of the Colossus is objectively an overrated game. Unless you are going to fundamentally disagree on the points I already brought up in which case I will question if you have even played the game.

Bought last guardian.. playing it atm .. one thing - fps drops are real, but so is the cuteness of Trico

This post was edited by Rushe on Dec 7 2016 12:46pm