Quote (downding @ Jan 24 2012 10:15am)
I've been hearing this with people trying out squire builds. His huge health seems really useful cushion at nightmare. But I suspect he's not as viable until you start hitting those high end stats. I'm guessing you're about 2-2.5k stats. Mages can easily clearing non-boss nightmare maps with pretty lowish stats. Don't believe squires can do this, though I could be wrong. Also, them squire harpoons can be pretty rage inducing/hilarious. Their AI targetting etc. probably could use a tweak. You ever seen 4 harpoons miss a mini-goblin a gazillion times for a minute as he marches from spawn up to your barricade line? I have. ^^ I think that was when I started to love my ensnare auras.
As for huntress dps. Maybe not better, but definitely more effective, efficient, and nightmare viable I should think. The mage's 5 shot spread still doesn't quite compete with the disc's duo pierce for mob control, and you have to be awfully close to get all those shots on an ogre, don't you? Then again, I don't have a 6 million dps apprentice.
You are correct about my current squire stats but when I started gearing for NM, I still only had my squire at the time at about 800 all around stats and was able to complete spire on him with ensnare help. The beautiful, but annoying thing about the slice and dice tower, even at 1k stats it can fair well in NM if used correctly. Now the annoying thing is that a 100 point jump in tower dmg isn't going to make you do uber amounts more of dps. If I could remember stats or log in I would provide a better example, but tower dmg for slice and dice towers will not boost your overall dps by anything noteworthy. There is something to be said for a tower that has 300k+ life, that has the ability to do over 250k dps. (As an afterthought, they're also pretty damn spider proof. The webbing only effects 'spin up time', and with the right 'aoe' tower stats, this can easily spin up to max before spiders even get a chance to throw a web)
Harpoons on the other hand at 3 stars with the stats/guardian app I have, can do 200k+ a hit in NM .. And pierce infinite numbers of enemies, the major drawback here is that the target definitely needs some work and they dont shoot for where the target is going, but just where the target is at, so unless you place these well, and in a straight line with where the enemy comes from, you miss a majority of the shots.