d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > Ladder Slasher > Unexpected Market Search Result
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 8,545
Joined: Oct 4 2021
Gold: 281.64
Mar 20 2022 06:16pm
If this is expected, my apologies - it seemed like either I am not understanding the context or potentially an and, if, or logic was not working the way I expected.

It seems as if searching for Fishing rods "OR" items I can use, instead of fishing rods "and" items I can use. (Screenshots below for clarity)

I was able to reproduce this with weapons, and armors so I believe the search is functioning this way holistically. This may just be me not understanding the checkbox, it seems its actually an option for "Show me items my class can use" as it shows items outside your level/skill range. As this overrides the above dropdown I was just not expecting it lower on the menu than the subtype dropdown. Obviously this is incredibly low hanging fruit and impacts nobody, but just sharing my observations.

Repro steps:
When you toggle on "show only what I can use" in the Market place search, it will display things outside of the subtype dropdown. It does not factor your level, or skill when filtering items on screen. (Player level requirement, or skill level requirement (fishing))


TLDR Suggestions: Remove the checkbox for "only show items I can use" and:
  • Create a new dropdown value for the sub-type dropdown list for "only show items my class can use".
  • Create a new dropdown value for the sub-type dropdown list for "only show items I can use" - This new value will only display items that meet the level/skill requirement of the searching character






This post was edited by Cascadian on Mar 20 2022 06:19pm
Member
Posts: 3,749
Joined: Sep 9 2009
Gold: Locked
Mar 20 2022 06:28pm
for items and objects that checkbox is irrelevant, for weapons armors and charms it works as intended

showing what your character can use is already implemented by red background
Member
Posts: 8,545
Joined: Oct 4 2021
Gold: 281.64
Mar 20 2022 06:31pm
Quote (peterqwer @ 20 Mar 2022 17:28)
for items and objects that checkbox is irrelevant, for weapons armors and charms it works as intended

showing what your character can use is already implemented by red background


It works as I describe for weapons and armors as well, you can see many non axes, and items outside of my character level:
*edit* unless you believe that "only show items I can use" should show items outside your skill level, or player level (i.e. cannot actually use them) or that it works as intended to override results (or search) instead of (and search)



This post was edited by Cascadian on Mar 20 2022 06:33pm
Member
Posts: 3,749
Joined: Sep 9 2009
Gold: Locked
Mar 20 2022 06:34pm
Quote (Cascadian @ 21 Mar 2022 01:31)
It works as I describe for weapons and armors as well, you can see many non axes, and items outside of my character level:
*edit* unless you believe that "only show items I can use" should show items outside your skill level, or player level (i.e. cannot actually use them) or that it works as intended to override results (or search) instead of (and search)

https://i.imgur.com/nI7YTtE.png


you can use them you just have to level up :p
Member
Posts: 8,545
Joined: Oct 4 2021
Gold: 281.64
Mar 20 2022 06:35pm
Quote (peterqwer @ 20 Mar 2022 17:34)
you can use them you just have to level up :p


If that is expected, rename it to "items my class can use" - solved :) but I think the functionality can be enhanced with minor tweaks to the UX and search calculations :)
Member
Posts: 30,419
Joined: Oct 29 2008
Gold: 542,882.81
Mar 20 2022 08:15pm
With a little more practice, you will never use this search mod. Its more for brand new players to find something fast to use.

Always search for all classes, better way overall.
Member
Posts: 48,937
Joined: Dec 17 2005
Gold: 52.69
Mar 20 2022 08:20pm
The search function is working as intended. It simply filters out items that your class cannot possibly equip. If you want to filter out items you can only specifically use at your level, click the checkbox AND put a level requirement in the appropriate field above.
Member
Posts: 52,944
Joined: Nov 2 2007
Gold: 273.10
Mar 21 2022 08:05am
Quote (Cascadian @ Mar 20 2022 08:16pm)
If this is expected, my apologies - it seemed like either I am not understanding the context or potentially an and, if, or logic was not working the way I expected.

It seems as if searching for Fishing rods "OR" items I can use, instead of fishing rods "and" items I can use. (Screenshots below for clarity)

I was able to reproduce this with weapons, and armors so I believe the search is functioning this way holistically. This may just be me not understanding the checkbox, it seems its actually an option for "Show me items my class can use" as it shows items outside your level/skill range. As this overrides the above dropdown I was just not expecting it lower on the menu than the subtype dropdown. Obviously this is incredibly low hanging fruit and impacts nobody, but just sharing my observations.

Repro steps:
When you toggle on "show only what I can use" in the Market place search, it will display things outside of the subtype dropdown. It does not factor your level, or skill when filtering items on screen. (Player level requirement, or skill level requirement (fishing))


TLDR Suggestions: Remove the checkbox for "only show items I can use" and:
  • Create a new dropdown value for the sub-type dropdown list for "only show items my class can use".
  • Create a new dropdown value for the sub-type dropdown list for "only show items I can use" - This new value will only display items that meet the level/skill requirement of the searching character



https://i.imgur.com/YhzFmwD.png
https://i.imgur.com/XXI6wjI.png


if you want to search by item level you can add that in. search function works perfectly fine

Quote (Newb. @ Mar 20 2022 10:20pm)
The search function is working as intended. It simply filters out items that your class cannot possibly equip. If you want to filter out items you can only specifically use at your level, click the checkbox AND put a level requirement in the appropriate field above.


this

This post was edited by LabattBlue on Mar 21 2022 08:05am
Go Back To Ladder Slasher Topic List
Add Reply New Topic New Poll