So.. first of all, it's safe to say that this game had me hooked from the start. It's so simple, yet so complex..

I'm just wondering specifically regarding the master quest.
I've failed it now 3 times, each and every single time I went with the key to the far right (silver). Now I'm starting to wonder, is it random each time & have I really just gotten unlucky with my 50/50 or what is going on

It's all random
I'm about 60 fails on Warlock already and I go silver first.

I have more keys.. but I'm lucky to get 1 in 🤣

It's totally random, no need to overthink. Some people stick to the same key order every time. I personally just random throw them in there every attempt.

It's weird, I'm convinced it's not just some random order. There's a couple possibilities I believe. Like, it's either gonna let you pass or fail as soon as you start the MQ, and the keys don't do anything. Or there's a weighted code to roll a number and that's how many doors you open, regardless of order. IDK. So many things about this game we don't know for sure. Lol

Yeah no I’m with you on the part that as soon as you open the quest it has already decided your faith for you
Guess I’m going to have to try a 4th time and pick the same key, I’m not letting go of it

It's such a dumb little thing too. But there's no more feeling of excitement/happiness than seeing the door open lol.

Except that little sound that plays when you gain a prof level. I fucking love that sound