guild only game means for me that all are getting the drop. so if someone wants it he has to donate a fair amount to the other if he wants to keep it. if the members of the run decide to keep it in guild usable for all noone will get fg, but it also wont be sold. if it gets sold all should get the same amount of fg.

so basically its not urs, its the item of all whoch did the climb. just my (our) point of view

other way to handle it: sell the item and use the fg for the good of the guild like buying exfer days or guild items.

This post was edited by derDrops on Feb 21 2011 07:18am

Rus, I love your passion for ladder slasher and you are a valued member of Empire guild. But this matter should be kept to pms. If I had a problem with you selling this item, I certainly would have pm'd you about it or told you on vent. Everyone has their own opinions on how things should be done, but in the end, none of that really matters as long as you do your best to respect others and are using this site for what it is intended..... fun. Let's close this topic and if you need any answers to your questions please just pm me. No need drama. God knows I have had enough drama for 3 lifetimes on this site

vouch this, i think this is the way every guild should do things, if its a full guild run, if item is sold its split 5 ways maybe a few K extra to the grabber. HI Nate!!!!

This post was edited by kermitdafrog on Feb 21 2011 07:21am

Please close the topic.

Thanks Nate for such a fantastic guild you have.

I don't get this thread... An Item Found in a Guild only Game should Be Shared between the Players Inside!

That's like saying finding an item from a group with many random slashers who did 1-71. They put in the time and effort just as much as a guild only.

Not sure why guild drama is brought to public thread.
All that I can say is if that dropped in a guild only in our guild, it wouldn't leave... (but I know at least 2 of us would pay what it's worth to keep it )

In the end it's your item and you can do with it as you please. I know some guilds who create bogus sale threads to get prices for their guildies. Although I 100% disagree with this method, at least the guildies are given first shot at the item and an accurate price is given. In my eyes, I think that's how it should be. In UA, I wouldn't expect to get the charm for say 20k fg. However, I would expect for the thing not to be sold w/o interested parties giving the blessing they aren't willing to pay more.

This post was edited by Stok3d on Feb 21 2011 08:00am

stupid thread.

sell it,profit,etc.

Whoever gets the item after the game-generated roll is the item owner.

Anyone claiming anything else is sucking swamp-water thru a soda straw

BUT, if you really want to get sticky about it, all items are the property of njaguar, and we play with them with his permission.

Don't get me wrong, I think what you think.

Random luck of the draw, that person is the winner and therefore decides what to do with it.