d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > Ladder Slasher >
Poll > Right Key Or The Left Key > That Is The Question
Prev1234568Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 12,396
Joined: Sep 17 2005
Gold: 15,132.59
Feb 12 2019 11:30am
used 213 for about 10 attempts and failed the lot, mostly fdf's. 123 worked for me twice in a row on the same day.
Not done that many attempts with monks as it's annoying to climb with and i'm trying to get some more drops, which means solo :P


I would suggest it doesn't matter what you do, I would probably recommend sticking to whatever you do.
It's like rolling a dice and you want the quickest way to be correct. If you choose the same number over and over, it feels more likely to happen than if you guess every single dice throw.

Mathematically it doesn't make any difference what you do. you have a 1 in 720 chance.
If that scares you, just remember all the other alch's have that horrendous chance too :P

On the plus side, there's a 25% chance you'll have already passed before you reach 210 MQ's on your alchemist.

Good luck Ant!
Do a single 361452 for me, :D (the chances suggest it'll be a fdf, but as i said, they're all equal anyway)


now i'm running away cos i used maths and izparagoni has seen the topic.
If you're wondering why i didnt say 29% or more ( 210/720 = 29.1667%), you need to remember that you can have 720 attempts and not pass. Theoretically even on a feeder class. So using attempts/(amount of keys)! isn't correct. If you didnt understand the !, dont argue please, if you understoof the !, then you probably already know the maths.

This post was edited by mclarke on Feb 12 2019 11:36am
Member
Posts: 40,183
Joined: Apr 29 2006
Gold: 20,826.51
Feb 12 2019 11:31am
Quote (AntTheProtagonist @ Feb 13 2019 06:19am)
Very much so about keys. There may also be subterranean meanings behind the thread. However the primary purpose is to get a good idea on how everyone opens their doors and which key they would recommend should I stray from normalcy.


Just stick to one set pattern of keys, like myself and some others.

When kirby (guild i am in) members were more active, it was funny how they would do like 15+ runs with 1 key set in mind and fail on 4th door, so then they change it just once and boom, failed... and they rage about changing it because if they stuck with what they normally used, they would have passed.

That is Murphy for you.
Member
Posts: 52,945
Joined: Nov 2 2007
Gold: 273.10
Feb 12 2019 11:34am
for some reason one of the keys always appears shinier to me, so i pick that one
Member
Posts: 60,523
Joined: Nov 28 2006
Gold: 375.00
Feb 12 2019 11:35am
Quote (LabattBlue @ Feb 12 2019 12:34pm)
for some reason one of the keys always appears shinier to me, so i pick that one


You are shinier to me! So I pick you!
Member
Posts: 18,172
Joined: Mar 15 2008
Gold: 67,650.04
Feb 12 2019 11:40am
Quote (mclarke @ Feb 12 2019 07:30am)
used 213 for about 10 attempts and failed the lot, mostly fdf's. 123 worked for me twice in a row on the same day.
Not done that many attempts with monks as it's annoying to climb with and i'm trying to get some more drops, which means solo :P


I would suggest it doesn't matter what you do, I would probably recommend sticking to whatever you do.
It's like rolling a dice and you want the quickest way to be correct. If you choose the same number over and over, it feels more likely to happen than if you guess every single dice throw.

Mathematically it doesn't make any difference what you do. you have a 1 in 720 chance.
If that scares you, just remember all the other alch's have that horrendous chance too :P

On the plus side, when you reach 210 MQ's on alch there's more than a 25% chance you've passed.

Good luck Ant!
Do a single 361452 for me, :D (the chances suggest it'll be a fdf, but as i said, they're all equal anyway)


now i'm running away cos i used maths and izparagoni has seen the topic.
If you're wondering why i didnt say 29% or more ( 210/720 = 29.1667%), you need to remember that you can have 720 attempts and not pass. Theoretically even on a feeder class. So using attempts/(amount of keys)! isn't correct. If you didnt understand the !, dont argue please, if you understoof the !, then you probably already know the maths.


Don’t worry mclarke. Even if Rex thought that Ant passing at 210/720 meant the chance to pass was 29%, we still have the raw data, so we can analyze the pass rate ourselves. If we weren’t convinced that the pass rate was 1/720 either, we could just have Ant run more trials. By probability theory, the more trials we run, the closer we get to the true %. Maybe by the time Ant has 15 or 20 resets we’ll be within a couple % of the true value :thumbsup:
Member
Posts: 40,183
Joined: Apr 29 2006
Gold: 20,826.51
Feb 12 2019 11:47am
Quote (mclarke @ Feb 13 2019 06:30am)
now i'm running away cos i used maths and izparagoni has seen the topic.
If you're wondering why i didnt say 29% or more ( 210/720 = 29.1667%), you need to remember that you can have 720 attempts and not pass. Theoretically even on a feeder class. So using attempts/(amount of keys)! isn't correct. If you didnt understand the !, dont argue please, if you understoof the !, then you probably already know the maths.


Quote (BWConformity @ Feb 13 2019 06:40am)
Don’t worry mclarke. Even if Rex thought that Ant passing at 210/720 meant the chance to pass was 29%, we still have the raw data, so we can analyze the pass rate ourselves. If we weren’t convinced that the pass rate was 1/720 either, we could just have Ant run more trials. By probability theory, the more trials we run, the closer we get to the true %. Maybe by the time Ant has 15 or 20 resets we’ll be within a couple % of the true value :thumbsup:


:rofl: I like those comments. No, I have to say that Murphy rules the odds for using the correct key, I never use calculation when it comes to Murphys' Law.
Member
Posts: 27,685
Joined: May 14 2013
Gold: 18,106.85
Feb 12 2019 11:49am
Quote (AntTheProtagonist @ Feb 12 2019 08:19pm)
Very much so about keys. There may also be subterranean meanings behind the thread. However the primary purpose is to get a good idea on how everyone opens their doors and which key they would recommend should I stray from normalcy.


Okay, I'm offering everyone the forbidden knowledge. Read carefully!

Next climb you do, pick a random key. If you don't fail, pick another random key etc until you fail, but memorize/write down what you've picked.

Lets say your combo was 2 3 5 4 6 1 and you 4df.

The numerical value of all the keys you picked, which opened a door, will be the order they are drawn in the next time.

In this case your new combo will be x 2 3 x 5 x . Also, the key which failed, will not be drawn in the order of it's numerical value next time.

So if key 4 failed you at the 4th door, it won't be the 4th key in your new combo, so it must be either first or last in this case.

Lets say you go for 4 2 3 1 5 6 for your next combo and you 3df. Key 3 won't be 3d in your new combo and keys 4 and 2 will be 4th and 2nd respectively.

So the new combo will be x 2 x 4 x x and key 3 won't be 3d.

If you fdf your next climb with whatever key you decided to pick, then you restart, but have in mind that key won't be "x" where x is it's number in the next climb.





Member
Posts: 12,396
Joined: Sep 17 2005
Gold: 15,132.59
Feb 12 2019 11:53am
Quote (BWConformity @ Feb 12 2019 05:40pm)
Don’t worry mclarke. Even if Rex thought that Ant passing at 210/720 meant the chance to pass was 29%, we still have the raw data, so we can analyze the pass rate ourselves. If we weren’t convinced that the pass rate was 1/720 either, we could just have Ant run more trials. By probability theory, the more trials we run, the closer we get to the true %. Maybe by the time Ant has 15 or 20 resets we’ll be within a couple % of the true value :thumbsup:


It is an interesting thought if the game manipulates the pass rates.

For How many of the completed Resets had less than 500 attempts from all the alchs? In theory that's your 50% value, so would be intriguing to look through, unfortunately i dont think the numbers are kept anywhere as even the attempts arn't kept separate.

If the amount is significantly above half, then perhaps the chance isnt 1/720 :P
Member
Posts: 18,172
Joined: Mar 15 2008
Gold: 67,650.04
Feb 12 2019 12:00pm
Quote (mclarke @ Feb 12 2019 07:53am)
It is an interesting thought if the game manipulates the pass rates.

For How many of the completed Resets had less than 500 attempts from all the alchs? In theory that's your 50% value, so would be intriguing to look through, unfortunately i dont think the numbers are kept anywhere as even the attempts arn't kept separate.

If the amount is significantly above half, then perhaps the chance isnt 1/720 :P


No idea about that... and for this topic... truth be told I don’t actually believe that what you pick is just the key... I believe you pick the right key at the right time :P

Say the correct key is the right key... but you take a whole second to decide that it’s right... by then maybe the left key is right and you picked the wrong key at the right time (or the right key at the wrong time) ... oh no, I’ve gone cross-eyed.
Member
Posts: 9,268
Joined: Nov 27 2007
Gold: 25.05
Feb 12 2019 12:00pm
Sooo what your really trying to sayyyyyyyyyyyyyyy is!!??!

Go Back To Ladder Slasher Topic List
Prev1234568Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll