d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > Ladder Slasher > Melee Damage Cleared Up > Quotes From Njaguar
Prev1234
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 33,497
Joined: Mar 15 2006
Gold: 17,130.79
Oct 12 2010 07:03am
Quote (stiffleronfire @ 12 Oct 2010 14:55)
I don't get it. The last thread had Paul stating that everyone was wrong. This thread says the SAME thing......


Lol, actually you're right :wacko:

But there is one difference between this topic and others: no crying, no bitching :P
Member
Posts: 32,769
Joined: Oct 4 2005
Gold: 1.71
Oct 12 2010 07:07am
Quote (Svartermetalisk @ Oct 12 2010 07:23am)
Well melee got buffed but compare with my dagger damage: 770 average with a 142 50 dagger.

Your axe is clearly better and you have more stats then I did but slammed by far in average dmg.


What stats do you have for str/dex? Because I only have 256 combined stats since I am on hardcore. :P
Member
Posts: 76,776
Joined: Nov 2 2007
Gold: 74,459.17
Trader: Trusted
Oct 12 2010 07:18am
the ratio system just has to be reworked a bit.. something like 10/90 dagger, 70/70 axes, 80/50 staff or whatever would be better.. 100 total is simply a little mistake in maths.. this would be fair if you had to stat your points in str/dex like 50/50.. then all weapons would be the same.. but as you will stat as many points as you can into dex when you use a dagger.. axes simply cant reach this.

This post was edited by ahs_darkhunter on Oct 12 2010 07:18am
Member
Posts: 53,726
Joined: Aug 20 2008
Gold: 30.00
Oct 12 2010 07:21am
Quote (Natester @ Oct 12 2010 03:07pm)
What stats do you have for str/dex? Because I only have 256 combined stats since I am on hardcore.  :P


264 if I counted correctly

40 str / 224 Dex

Quote (Killer_Stride @ Oct 12 2010 03:22pm)
only? :rofl:


Yeah this lol.

Beast alert @ nate

This post was edited by Svartermetalisk on Oct 12 2010 07:23am
Member
Posts: 26,998
Joined: Jul 5 2007
Gold: 1,250.22
Oct 12 2010 07:22am
Quote (Natester @ Oct 12 2010 09:07am)
What stats do you have for str/dex? Because I only have 256 combined stats since I am on hardcore.  :P


only? :rofl:
Member
Posts: 72,809
Joined: Apr 11 2007
Gold: 3.00
Trader: Trusted
Oct 12 2010 08:07am
isnt this what i said how str/dex worked yet everyone said it didnt?...
Member
Posts: 32,769
Joined: Oct 4 2005
Gold: 1.71
Oct 12 2010 08:21am
Quote (Killer_Stride @ Oct 12 2010 09:22am)
only? :rofl:


That's good? :lol: :blush:
Member
Posts: 5,053
Joined: Jul 3 2006
Gold: 198.86
Oct 12 2010 11:16am
You know one thing that would even things out a little more?

Swap the ratios for Dagger and Staff. Staffs have less use, so therefore should get potential higher damage in my eyes. Clubs are fine on their end of the spectrum, since they cannot even be used past Pally.
Member
Posts: 5,497
Joined: Jun 24 2008
Gold: 220,909.04
Oct 12 2010 11:24am
Quote (stiffleronfire @ Oct 12 2010 01:16pm)
You know one thing that would even things out a little more?

Swap the ratios for Dagger and Staff. Staffs have less use, so therefore should get potential higher damage in my eyes. Clubs are fine on their end of the spectrum, since they cannot even be used past Pally.


I have 0 problem with this for completely selfish purposes. :D

Edit: (I recently switched from Dagger/Axe to Sword/Staff.)

This post was edited by Edball on Oct 12 2010 11:26am
Member
Posts: 27,011
Joined: Apr 11 2006
Gold: 0.70
Oct 12 2010 04:03pm
Quote (arxyn @ Oct 13 2010 01:38am)
Isn't this the same conclusion we had from the other thread though...?

I think I'm misunderstanding something.


The last thread was closed after paul said everyone was wrong, and that someone should do some research because he's said it all before.


This is what I came up with - it seems we weren't wrong. He said this himself so I'm not sure how it can possibly be incorrect.
Go Back To Ladder Slasher Topic List
Prev1234
Add Reply New Topic New Poll