I very highly dislike the idea. I don't think this game would even be worth playing if something like this was implemented. Making things free and easy is never a good choice in life or in games.

There can't just be gear freely available (at no risk) for anyone who joins a guild which can afford a bunch of items for guild use. This game has already become so mind-numbingly easy when there are decent catacomb groups available. The last thing that's needed is for the biggest/richest guilds to be able to take any noob off of jsp and get them easily earning points for them as well. There has to be some challenge along the way here people .. and one of the last real challenges in this game is finding and buying good gear for yourself. That's half of what makes the game fun imo.

I'm sure those reasons don't cover half of why this would be a bad addition to the game.

This post was edited by mwm_zyxcba on Dec 3 2009 09:18pm

I very like this new idea

Vote yes to this for sure

Sounds cool for me, I'd like to see such thing implemented !
Maybe not everything, but atleast the part with guild items, and letting others use them without ability to delete/sell it.

option 1

we would be right back at the problem that causing the muting nerf
items were undervalued and everyone had access to everything

First : Guilds allready share gear between members useing Guild Transfer So how this will change anything ?? And who told you that it'll be "extriemely easy" to put gear on Guild Arsenal ?? It can be chargable and restricted to only few items per guild. I know that whole idea need more work



It'll wouldnt be fair to say why ??

This post was edited by mar_j on Dec 4 2009 03:23am

very nice but seems unlikely that paul would do something of this magnitude.

Good Idea

Great idea but I don't think it will happen. Also: It looks alot like the WoW guild thingies.

Sorry, but I voted no.

1) Guild Arsenal
This is the only part that I kind of like, but it would need some more tweaking done to it.
edit : hmmm, and really the more I think about it, the vault/guild transfer options work fine just the way it's set up now.

2) Guild Hall of Fame
I don't think this is necessary.

3) Guild Vault
I could only see this being a mess. The way it is now seems perfectly fine. Buy a vault, buy guild transfer rights...guildmates can transfer items back and forth to eachother AND controll who gets to use them.

4) Portal
you can message people in-game...this seems like it would be like the "chatroom" that nobody ever used. (and was removed in a previous patch/update)

you had some interesting ideas, but I just don't agree.

This post was edited by Brainwashed on Dec 4 2009 05:28am