d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > Ladder Slasher >
Poll > Another Vitality Thread > Defense Only
Prev123
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 27,746
Joined: Feb 17 2003
Gold: 11,271.01
Warn: 20%
May 23 2011 02:04am
Quote (Boss @ 23 May 2011 09:02)
Shut the fuck up already
Worth the suspension


lol
Member
Posts: 25,676
Joined: Jun 13 2006
Gold: 200.00
May 23 2011 02:07am
no more vit threads
or its time to change it to something else like what happened to parry

wheres the ban vit threads immediately poll?
Member
Posts: 18,768
Joined: Jan 5 2007
Gold: 1,053.71
May 23 2011 02:12am
I want cookies while I play ladder slasher.

If monsters are slightly improved everything its just fine. I mean there are some cool changes that this game can have but we can only dream about them.
Member
Posts: 33,512
Joined: Mar 15 2006
Gold: 20,150.79
May 23 2011 02:14am
I almost like it, because giving vitality the power to increase both magical and physical defense would be awesome, especially for robe characters, so you could boost your overall defense focusing only on one stat: vita.
When I want to tank with my ninja, my overall (avg) defense is lower than with my leather/scale armors and it's only because I'd need to put some more points into intelligence, which would be a waste of course.

I am giving null vote here, because it won't happen anyway and I prefer my suggestion to give +x life per 1 point of vitality.

Quote (izParagonzi @ 30 Apr 2011 06:53)
Based on other threads about vitality, I thought this was a good suggestion.

Some of the posts in other threads state that adding X amount of life = overpowered
Some of the posts in other threads state that ratios for casting is making the game easier
This game is easy as it is... I will vote yes to this/that if the game was harder
et cetera


First of all, in my topic most of ppl wanted vitality to give +x life per vitality point

Quote
Would it be overpowered if vita from items worked similar to already stat'ed vita?
Yes  -->  37.31%  (25 Votes)
No, but it should be at less than 50% effectiveness  --> 10.45%  (7 Votes)
No, but it should be at 50% effectiveness  -->  19.40%  (13 Votes)
No, but it should be at 75% effectiveness  -->  1.49%  (1 Votes)
No  --> 31.34%  (21 Votes)


25 votes were against and 7+13+1+21 (42 votes) were supporting my suggestion


and second of all, in other thread (which made MrMoJoRising) it was about to make game harder, not easier. You said that you'd support his suggestion if it was about to make game harder and because you thought it wasn't you said that you don't like it.
Game is already easy and thanks to his suggestion it would definitely make game harder, but the reason why ppl didn't like his suggestion was because it would be ridiculous to stat vita and have almost no mana at all to cast with some types of charms.

Even though my thread was more like a win than all others I gave up and stopped bumping it. You should follow me.
(tbh, didn't even have to bump it at all)

This post was edited by barteq88 on May 23 2011 02:16am
Member
Posts: 40,191
Joined: Apr 29 2006
Gold: 20,558.41
May 23 2011 03:28am
Quote (barteq88 @ May 23 2011 08:14pm)
Even though my thread was more like a win than all others I gave up and stopped bumping it. You should follow me.
(tbh, didn't even have to bump it at all)


2 other Threads on the same day about the same topic got people tired of posting or commenting by the time this post went up.
So i decided to let this slide to see if people would think a bit more clearly... and clearly some of the previous comments show
that i was incorrect... but staying on subject matter:

Quote
Would it be overpowered if vita from items worked similar to already stat'ed vita?
Yes  -->  37.31%  (25 Votes)
No, but it should be at less than 50% effectiveness  10.45%  (7 Votes)
No, but it should be at 50% effectiveness  -->  19.40%  (13 Votes)
No, but it should be at 75% effectiveness  -->  1.49%  (1 Votes)
No  31.34%  (21 Votes)


The % Ratios Votes are weighing up on both the YES / NO votes, thus Nullifying them.
End results are simple:

Q: Is it overpowered:
A: Yes (25)
A: NO (21)
___________

As for me also agree'ing with other thread, I realised that I was wrong... and yes it would be good to make the game harder, but then we
jeapordise the gameplay for new players... I have seen the increase to LS since 1.21 came out... even our guild has grown in numbers
of people that have not played the game, and there have been an increase of topics asking for help because they are new to the game...
Maybe a coincidence? We will not know.

This post was edited by izParagonzi on May 23 2011 03:29am
Member
Posts: 7,465
Joined: Jan 14 2006
Gold: 1.71
May 23 2011 05:17am
I voted yes. The reasons people will stat alot of vita is for the life boost and/or for tanking.
All other stats only serve one purpose other than intelligence: Str/Dex increases dmg, Vita increases phys def but intell increases charm/heal effectiveness AND magical def. Why not balance vita imo
Go Back To Ladder Slasher Topic List
Prev123
Add Reply New Topic New Poll