d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > Ladder Slasher >
Poll > New Proficiency Idea > Musical Instruments!
Prev12345Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 13,507
Joined: Feb 20 2006
Gold: 635.48
Oct 7 2009 11:54am
Quote (Yip12343 @ Wed, Oct 7 2009, 01:39pm)
No, this isnt a orchestra.. As Dream said, when do we use a instrument to kill someone / monster...

[x] Nope


So it doesn't have to be an instrument. The concept is still great, in my opinion.
It could use a few tweaks here and there, but I definitely see potential.
Member
Posts: 13,934
Joined: Jan 4 2004
Gold: 130,215.17
Oct 7 2009 12:21pm
to be honest, cata's are already easy enough, we dont need to make them easier.

same for healing. its already powerful enough
Member
Posts: 6,485
Joined: Apr 5 2005
Gold: 1,390.71
Oct 7 2009 12:39pm
Quote (k.iMpacT @ Wed, Oct 7 2009, 01:21pm)
to be honest, cata's are already easy enough, we dont need to make them easier.

same for healing. its already powerful enough


agreed
Member
Posts: 40,183
Joined: Apr 29 2006
Gold: 20,826.51
Oct 7 2009 01:42pm
Null Vote...

Besides the Leeching part in Catas (even though you have to click per pack)... I have to agree that it is overpowered.
Also the conflicts in coding could be a right Biatche... trying to figure out what is an actual Glyph item and the musical instrument.

Also... wouldn't the musical instrument also boost the power of the glyph?... also maybe another conflict
Member
Posts: 14,325
Joined: Jul 4 2007
Gold: 859.70
Oct 7 2009 01:56pm
Wow, insightful feedback, indeed.

I never play softcore, so I didn't fully consider leechers......................
What if.................
It was Hardcore Only? Nobody tapes their arrow down and goes afk in hardcore.

Music would stack with glyphs. I have no idea about programming, if that's a coding nightmare, but here's another coding nightmare that I mentioned that nobody seems to have noticed....
Musical Life Steal. An instrument with a LS or lpk/a mod would work!

And, after seeing how much people feel this would be overpowered, you would need to have the required level and required proficiency level to use an instrument.
Member
Posts: 57,889
Joined: May 23 2007
Gold: 0.00
Oct 7 2009 02:00pm
way too overpowered imo.
if the item was temporary ... then maybe.
Member
Posts: 14,325
Joined: Jul 4 2007
Gold: 859.70
Oct 7 2009 02:12pm
Quote (Greapper @ Wed, 7 Oct 2009, 14:00)
way too overpowered imo.
if the item was temporary ... then maybe.


It is temporary. Only effective while you play it.
Member
Posts: 40,183
Joined: Apr 29 2006
Gold: 20,826.51
Oct 7 2009 02:26pm
Quote (AF_Warren666 @ Thu, Oct 8 2009, 07:56am)
Wow, insightful feedback, indeed.

I never play softcore, so I didn't fully consider leechers......................
What if.................
It was Hardcore Only? Nobody tapes their arrow down and goes afk in hardcore.

Music would stack with glyphs. I have no idea about programming, if that's a coding nightmare, but here's another coding nightmare that I mentioned that nobody seems to have noticed....
Musical Life Steal. An instrument with a LS or lpk/a mod would work!

And, after seeing how much people feel this would be overpowered, you would need to have the required level and required proficiency level to use an instrument.


Hardcore will then get Leechers in Catacombs...
Also gaining proficiencies is a no brainer... within a month or two... you will have a person with Rank10 in this musical instrument.
Also a well organised Guild (team/party) that know that they have this at their disposal will take full benefit of its potential.

As for the overpowering thing... I was more thinking of the +STAT items and the %EE items... how does this musical instrument deal
with +30 STR/DEX/INT/VITA items and also deal with 35+ % Heal Mastery?... then there is the 150+% Enhanced Effect items like
weapons and heal charms?

Forget LPK/MPK etc... those other items to me with enhancement make it overpowered.

Maybe I am reading it wrong... this is how I read it:
Play Flute (Rank10)... giving the Party 10% enhanced effect to their items abilities.

Barb has:
+80 Str (2 items)
+50 Dex (1 item)
+30 Int (1 item)
... +15 Str (Glyph)
... +20 Dex (Glyph)
... +18 Int (Glyph)

Now 10% enhancement by person playing Flute Adds to:
Str: 9.5 (89.5)
Dex: 7 (77)
Int: 4.8 (52.8)

Can you see the implementation to a well setup Caster or Hybrid?

Then it adds to the % Enhanced Effect of the item used... whether it is a weapon or charm.
________________

This is not including FISH/COMFREYS that have been "Suffusensed"...
________________

Idea is nice... but I can see how this can be overpowering... but then I could be wrong... and read it wrong...
Member
Posts: 9,891
Joined: Nov 8 2005
Gold: 140.00
Oct 7 2009 02:30pm
I don't play WOW for a reason.
Admin
Posts: 24,840
Joined: Sep 24 2002
Gold: 43,367.72
Trader: Trusted
Oct 7 2009 03:19pm
That's funny, I have a prototype spec'd out for this exact thing. A big throw-back to the Bard's Tale days. :)

Whether or not I'll add it or not, I don't know, however. (Balance, etc)
Go Back To Ladder Slasher Topic List
Prev12345Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll