Quote (Cheeya @ Aug 25 2018 01:08pm)
That would get an even bigger HELL NO vote than this did...
Armor prof makes no sense. If a shield item was introduced I would be willing to concede on a blocking prof... every one knows the phalanx was a shield proficiency formation so i guess you can get better at "shield wearing" but never ever will i say "wow you wore tank armor for 10 climbs? you should totally get a bonus for wearing that armor progressively better!"
I agree, armor prof is pointless, as I have stated in previous "Armor Prof" threads that pop up... I have worn Scale / chain / plate armor irl, the only requirements are: enough strength to don the armor efficiently to move freely while swinging your weapon or combo holding a shield as well. Phalanx are more spear shield combat efficient as a UNIT, Sword/Pilum and Shield users, Romans were basically masters at it (again, as a Unit). Since I have been a Praetorian and mercenary in contact (full and non full) re-enactment groups, I agree 100% that while using a Shield, you get a block prof, but, then you have to add a "Feint" prof to bypass a shield block (or increasing the % chance to hit an opponent)
EDIT: damn got too engrossed in this post that I burnt the frying pan... Grrr...
This post was edited by izParagonzi on Aug 24 2018 07:23pm