d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > Ladder Slasher >
Poll > Suggestion: Loan In Market Place > Ls Poll
Prev1234Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 30,015
Joined: Aug 8 2007
Gold: 0.00
Nov 16 2009 05:54pm
Quote (Goss3N @ Nov 16 2009 06:53pm)
wont happen :/


keep your mind open please
i rarely see any of those suggestion got to paul

couldn't hurt to try imo
Member
Posts: 10,264
Joined: Jan 18 2009
Gold: 4.30
Nov 16 2009 06:00pm
Quote (izParagonzi @ Nov 17 2009 01:53am)
The idea seems sound.

What happens when the person you loan it... deletes character with that item on? 
1. Would it say: "Can not be deleted as there is a Loaned item on the character!"
2. Would it give you the option to "Send Loaned Items Back to Owner" BEFORE deleting your character <--- this sounds good
3. Would it automatically give it back to the Owner? <--- this

With those above... what happens if that character that put it on the MP is full of items... and can not accept anymore?
1. Does it "Auto-Add" even if character is full? <--- ofc like its with mp items when they dont sell.. ^^
2. Does it "Send to Next Available Character that has a slot open"
______________

Do not get me wrong... I like the idea... and voted yes... but just looking at some of the mishaps to incorporating this function.



i like evry input..

but ppl who vote n because of "wont happen" <--- i just lol about tham ... ( get ur +1 in other topics )
i rly dont blame anyone with a good reason

This post was edited by Bmy1 on Nov 16 2009 06:02pm
Member
Posts: 57,889
Joined: May 23 2007
Gold: 0.00
Nov 16 2009 06:03pm
Quote (Bmy1 @ 17 Nov 2009 08:45)
and when 30 days ended, the item return to the owner automatically
also, that item wont be able to be delete or changed from those skills (transmute, etc)


I don't like it.
It would be really shitty if your 55 MQ weapon that you were borrowing from someone just poofed when you hit 55 (because the time is up) & you have no fg to buy / rent another one.

Really loans should be kept within the guild... that's what the vault is for & also part of joining a guild (to borrow items from other members)
It solidifies the guild friendship / trust more.

@ the bolded part... Paul would have to change a lot of the game coding just to incorporate this.
Not being able to accidentally shrine the item, not allowing it to be glyphed, not allowing it to be transmuted, not allowing the person renting it to loan it out to someone else, not letting them transfer the item to a guildy... It would be way more trouble than it's worth.

I don't see Paul changing it.
sorry.
Member
Posts: 8,757
Joined: Sep 16 2007
Gold: 133.94
Nov 16 2009 06:04pm
great idea, i always thought about how to implement a rental system... never came up with this idea

just to add a suggestion: maybe the rent'd item should hava a different collor text, like Green or something. and this item ofc could not be shrined
Member
Posts: 10,264
Joined: Jan 18 2009
Gold: 4.30
Nov 16 2009 06:07pm
Quote (Greapper @ Nov 17 2009 02:03am)
I don't like it.
It would be really shitty if your 55 MQ weapon that you were borrowing from someone just poofed when you hit 55 (because the time is up) & you have no fg to buy / rent another one.

Really loans should be kept within the guild... that's what the vault is for & also part of joining a guild (to borrow items from other members)
It solidifies the guild friendship / trust more.

@ the bolded part... Paul would have to change a lot of the game coding just to incorporate this.
Not being able to accidentally shrine the item, not allowing it to be glyphed, not allowing it to be transmuted, not allowing the person renting it to loan it out to someone else, not letting them transfer the item to a guildy... It would be way more trouble than it's worth.

I don't see Paul changing it.
sorry.


hmm ok the coding thing is the only good reason i heard... but i think paul could handle it ^^

Quote (legirotto @ Nov 17 2009 02:04am)
great idea, i always thought about how to implement a rental system... never came up with this idea

just to add a suggestion: maybe the rent'd item should hava a different collor text, like Green or something. and this item ofc could not be shrined


thx for input...
nice idea...
Member
Posts: 18,719
Joined: Nov 14 2006
Gold: 2,016.48
Nov 16 2009 06:12pm
To many things have to change to make it work

Besides we alreay have something that lets us do the same thing: Item Vault
Member
Posts: 30,015
Joined: Aug 8 2007
Gold: 0.00
Nov 16 2009 06:13pm
Quote (Greapper @ Nov 16 2009 07:03pm)
I don't like it[B].
It would be really shitty if your 55 MQ weapon that you were borrowing from someone just poofed when you hit 55 (because the time is up) & you have no fg to buy / rent another one.
[/B]

Really loans should be kept within the guild... that's what the vault is for & also part of joining a guild (to borrow items from other members)
It solidifies the guild friendship / trust more.

@ the bolded part... Paul would have to change a lot of the game coding just to incorporate this.
Not being able to accidentally shrine the item, not allowing it to be glyphed, not allowing it to be transmuted, not allowing the person renting it to loan it out to someone else, not letting them transfer the item to a guildy... It would be way more trouble than it's worth.

I don't see Paul changing it.
sorry.


about one marked in red
so, that's point of loan

solution
they should give like 3 days warning before it return to owner
so you can know what to do before they poof back to their owner
Member
Posts: 10,264
Joined: Jan 18 2009
Gold: 4.30
Nov 16 2009 06:16pm
Quote (DevilWithin17 @ Nov 17 2009 02:12am)
To many things have to change to make it work

Besides we alreay have something that lets us do the same thing: Item Vault


lol not rly...

what if some one dont got a guild or.. is a friend of urs but other guild and u dont wana risk a snipe with never return item?
than it would be better to put it on the "loan market" he could pick it up use it .. bla bla bla.. after 30 days u do it again..
Member
Posts: 8,044
Joined: Jul 30 2007
Gold: 8,118.97
Nov 16 2009 06:18pm
Quote (Bmy1 @ Nov 17 2009 12:16am)
lol not rly...

what if some one dont got a guild or.. is a friend of urs but other guild and u dont wana risk a snipe with never return item?
than it would be better to put it on the "loan market" he could pick it up use it .. bla bla bla.. after 30 days u do it again..


Then you could put that item up for it's normal value price, the guy buys it and vice versa when you want it back.

And besides, people already complain about item prices being low and what not, adding a new feature that encourages NOT buying your own gear isn't the solution.

This post was edited by arxyn on Nov 16 2009 06:19pm
Member
Posts: 40,183
Joined: Apr 29 2006
Gold: 20,826.51
Nov 16 2009 06:21pm
One thing I like about people that have more input...
It helps build up on the idea... so I have answered each point based on my preference

Quote (Greapper @ Nov 17 2009 12:03pm)
I don't like it.
It would be really shitty if your 55 MQ weapon that you were borrowing from someone just poofed when you hit 55 (because the time is up) & you have no fg to buy / rent another one.


This is the key problem... even if you are @ level 68 and then time runs out...

Quote (Greapper @ Nov 17 2009 12:03pm)
Really loans should be kept within the guild... that's what the vault is for & also part of joining a guild (to borrow items from other members)
It solidifies the guild friendship / trust more.


I concur on the Guild loans and everything... also incorporating trust within...
I personally think that the Vault / Xfer prices or Days need changing... I have spent around 600+ fg on it... and it is costly especially for those guilds that have few members.
The loaning idea here... gives a person a chance to make some fg... and also stops any snipers that are around

Quote (Greapper @ Nov 17 2009 12:03pm)
@ the bolded part... Paul would have to change a lot of the game coding just to incorporate this.
Not being able to accidentally shrine the item, not allowing it to be glyphed, not allowing it to be transmuted, not allowing the person renting it to loan it out to someone else, not letting them transfer the item to a guildy... It would be way more trouble than it's worth.

I don't see Paul changing it.
sorry.


As for the coding... there is nothing to it... he only needs to create a tag with rules... and that tag is automatically created with the "Loan" button...

And I am not sure if Paul would implement this... but it is good to see votes/opinions.
Even ways around issues may help with the implementation...
Go Back To Ladder Slasher Topic List
Prev1234Next
Closed New Topic New Poll