d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Globe Earth
Prev15675685695705711933Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 18,893
Joined: Apr 5 2008
Gold: Locked
Warn: 90%
Jan 19 2018 10:50pm
Quote (death_knight @ 19 Jan 2018 21:39)
Proving the mathematical existence of gravity as a function of entrophy is arbitrary

If you knew as much as you claim you would not ask anyone to try proving parameters such as gravity


If you think such an "effect" can be proven or disprove, it shows how little you know about quantum mechanics and clearly are mix matching concepts


I await your rebuttal



But if you want to split hairs the most basic "proof" of gravity is that every model is incomplete without the gravitational constant

Without such a constant all aeronautics much less vehicle suspension or anything that moves is mathematicalw impossible

Are you saying cars don't exist?


Checkmate.


Thread closed son
Member
Posts: 63,097
Joined: Jan 11 2005
Gold: 9,765.00
Warn: 60%
Jan 19 2018 10:54pm
Quote (death_knight @ Jan 19 2018 06:50pm)
But if you want to split hairs the most basic "proof" of gravity is that every model is incomplete without the gravitational constant

Without such a constant all aeronautics much less vehicle suspension or anything that moves is mathematicalw impossible

Are you saying cars don't exist?


Checkmate.


Thread closed son


cars dont work because of gravity, also did not claim cars dont exist - you did

Smashed


FE proved
Member
Posts: 27,520
Joined: Nov 13 2008
Gold: 5,265.08
Jan 19 2018 10:57pm
Quote (card_sultan @ Jan 19 2018 10:38pm)
oh that one, i got one for you hold your hand out straight for an hour - if your arm gets tired is that proof of gravity?

I see your thinking is still incapable of thinking beyond your bias that if you drop stuff, the only reason it fell is because of gravity.

good grief.

Here's a nice paper that shows Gravity is false.

Disproof of Gravity
By Aaron Guerami
aguerami@gmail.com
http://aaronsreality./
The standard particle model has yet to find any evidence of Gravity. This is most concerning since gravity
is used by most modern equations. Great particle accelerators have hunted for any signs of gravity. None
found!
There are several ways to disprove gravity.
1) Experimentally
One simple experiment shows there is no gravity. The Helium Balloon. It rises. How is this
possible? Classical Mechanics shows that Force equals the Constant of Gravity multiplied by the
Mass of Object 1 multiplied by the Mass of Object 2 divided by the Distance between the two
masses raised to the second power.
F=GM1M2/r^2
With this logic, the mass of the Earth is so great that the helium balloon would have no choice but
to be attracted to the Earth. We have mass 1 pulling on mass 2 and mass 2 pulling on mass 1.
F1 = F2. This is just wrong. The force of the balloon that pulls the Earth is not equal to the force
that the Earth pulls on the balloon. It would not rise. What we see in the experiment that the
helium is rising to meet its level of density.



this helium balloon experiment that you posted right at the beginning here, was already shown in the vsauce video i showed you guys....

the balloon is being pulled down to earth, but because it's surrounded by air, the air is being pulled FASTER than the balloon and, basically the air pushes the balloon out of the way
Member
Posts: 18,893
Joined: Apr 5 2008
Gold: Locked
Warn: 90%
Jan 19 2018 10:57pm
Quote (card_sultan @ 19 Jan 2018 21:49)
Entropy applies to thermodynamics, so your statement makes no sense besides grammatically.

If your claiming Gravity is real, then the burden of proof is on you to prove its existence.

If your claiming it is just a matter of faith - well then i agree and you should join me in my heretical rhetoric.

Quantum gravity has also been disproven, although it is quite a different concept then the usual claims of Newtonian gravity that only shows how this forum is pathetically misinformed and proud of it.


Careful with your terms

Thermodynamics applies to the universe as a whole system therefore gravity becomes a graphical function as the change of states due to the forces we are unable to identify as the most basic constituents, some can argue we know the smallest building block but of that's the case when will validity = 100%? Never because the formula denies it by definition

In other words the entrophy of a system contains the property of gravity in some form or another, some argue the strong and weak forces are of just smaller proportion


The issue is that defining terms is arbitrty to observation and obviously observation can be arbitrary in itself

How do i know the green my eyes see = yours? Good luck trying to find the answer


Argue terms all day? No progress

Apply the scientific method? Baby steps.
Member
Posts: 63,097
Joined: Jan 11 2005
Gold: 9,765.00
Warn: 60%
Jan 19 2018 11:01pm
Quote (caswallen @ Jan 19 2018 06:57pm)
this helium balloon experiment that you posted right at the beginning here, was already shown in the vsauce video i showed you guys....

the balloon is being pulled down to earth, but because it's surrounded by air, the air is being pulled FASTER than the balloon and, basically the air pushes the balloon out of the way


So air defies gravity, but did you know the air is also spinning and orbiting and spiralling with the earth at 500,000 mph and you are just too dumb to notice it?

if F = MA and air has a mass and is moving at 500,000 mph - where is the force?
Member
Posts: 27,520
Joined: Nov 13 2008
Gold: 5,265.08
Jan 19 2018 11:01pm
the air and the helium in the balloon are fighting eachother for it's spot to land... because the air is heavier and has MORE mass than helium... the air wins the fight and pushes the helium out of its way and what is that card?

THATS BUOYANCY CARD I THOUGHT YOU KNEW THAT
Member
Posts: 18,893
Joined: Apr 5 2008
Gold: Locked
Warn: 90%
Jan 19 2018 11:05pm
Quote (caswallen @ 19 Jan 2018 22:01)
the air and the helium in the balloon are fighting eachother for it's spot to land... because the air is heavier and has MORE mass than helium... the air wins the fight and pushes the helium out of its way and what is that card?

THATS BUOYANCY CARD I THOUGHT YOU KNEW THAT


Now here I have to agree with card

Where did you show your work?

Blindly passing second hand knowledge is exactly that

However demonstrating case(n) is much more effective at making a point ;)
Member
Posts: 27,520
Joined: Nov 13 2008
Gold: 5,265.08
Jan 19 2018 11:08pm
Quote (death_knight @ Jan 19 2018 11:05pm)
Now here I have to agree with card

Where did you show your work?

Blindly passing second hand knowledge is exactly that

However demonstrating case(n) is much more effective at making a point ;)


i don't have any paint skills to draw it out and show but its very simple, the helium is falling down right? and the air is falling down too right? but they don't fall at the same speed because they have different mass...

card was saying to me that helium floatiing upward means it couldn't have mass and therefore gravity isn't acting on the helium... which isn't the case... gravity is pulling the helium down but the air around it is being pulled faster resulting in the air pushing the helium out of its way
Member
Posts: 63,097
Joined: Jan 11 2005
Gold: 9,765.00
Warn: 60%
Jan 19 2018 11:08pm
Quote (death_knight @ Jan 19 2018 06:57pm)
Careful with your terms

Thermodynamics applies to the universe as a whole system therefore gravity becomes a graphical function as the change of states due to the forces we are unable to identify as the most basic constituents, some can argue we know the smallest building block but of that's the case when will validity = 100%? Never because the formula denies it by definition

In other words the entrophy of a system contains the property of gravity in some form or another, some argue the strong and weak forces are of just smaller proportion


The issue is that defining terms is arbitrty to observation and obviously observation can be arbitrary in itself

How do i know the green my eyes see = yours? Good luck trying to find the answer


Argue terms all day? No progress

Apply the scientific method? Baby steps.


Are you applying the theory of everything to explain your faith in gravity or it being a thermodynamic force.

What proof do you even have that gravity is a result of thermodynamics - you know your bypassing Newtonian and Einstein gravity for pure theory so i doubt you can prove anything,
Member
Posts: 63,909
Joined: Jun 26 2009
Gold: 169.70
Jan 19 2018 11:12pm
Quote (caswallen @ Jan 20 2018 02:31pm)
the air and the helium in the balloon are fighting eachother for it's spot to land... because the air is heavier and has MORE mass than helium... the air wins the fight and pushes the helium out of its way and what is that card?

THATS BUOYANCY CARD I THOUGHT YOU KNEW THAT


you just admitted the answer is buoyancy, because gravity is not real
Go Back To General Chat Topic List
Prev15675685695705711933Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll