d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Other Games > RuneScape >
Poll > Skill Comp Poll & Discussion
12Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 27,224
Joined: Nov 18 2013
Gold: 8,070.00
Dec 4 2022 09:47am
As some of you know I'm going to be running the skill comp and started this past week.

My idea is to possibly try and shake up how it's done each week.

I've put together this wheel with some screen recording software. With this, the chance of a b2b week IS possible however very unlikely.
Runecrafting may not be the best way to showcase this but it's just an example :) This will not affect the new Skill Comp starting in under 24 hours. This is merely to test the interest of such a thing.



It seems a 12 week cooldown is a tad bit long, and if we forego the wheel idea, I'd like to see how you guys think about shortening it down for 4 or 2 weeks.
The 2 week simply makes it so b2bs cannot happen.


I look forward to your responses and thinking behind them!

I'd also like to see how people feel about using either TempleOSRS or Wise Old Man.
Likes/dislikes/QoL things about either/or etc.

If you have any questions I'll answer them as soon as I can!

Happy Scapin'! B)
Member
Posts: 26,064
Joined: Dec 2 2014
Gold: 282.49
Dec 4 2022 10:14am
All for Wise Old Man, everyone i've spoken to seems to prefer it over TempleOsrs


Wheel spin would be a nice idea, fine with 2/4 week cooldown as well.


Thanks for keeping this going and inquiring with the community on how to proceed, cheers!
Member
Posts: 16,078
Joined: Jan 5 2011
Gold: 1,077.64
Dec 4 2022 12:26pm
I like random. Winners could always pick the skill they believe they will win next. So spices it up a little bit.

You could always do random without allowing back to back. So if it’s runecraft one week and it happens to roll on it again, it’ll be rerolled.

Not sure if my opinion/voice has weight as I’m not in the competitions anymore, but I used to be. I figured as someone who was in it, and who runs a competition similarly, I’d provide my thoughts.
Member
Posts: 12,690
Joined: Aug 30 2007
Gold: 16,001.00
Dec 4 2022 01:00pm
random
Member
Posts: 27,224
Joined: Nov 18 2013
Gold: 8,070.00
Dec 4 2022 02:47pm
Quote (LoveBear @ Dec 4 2022 08:14am)
All for Wise Old Man, everyone i've spoken to seems to prefer it over TempleOsrs


Wheel spin would be a nice idea, fine with 2/4 week cooldown as well.


Thanks for keeping this going and inquiring with the community on how to proceed, cheers!


You're very welcome & thank you for your thoughts!

Quote (Vorp @ Dec 4 2022 10:26am)
I like random. Winners could always pick the skill they believe they will win next. So spices it up a little bit.

You could always do random without allowing back to back. So if it’s runecraft one week and it happens to roll on it again, it’ll be rerolled.

Not sure if my opinion/voice has weight as I’m not in the competitions anymore, but I used to be. I figured as someone who was in it, and who runs a competition similarly, I’d provide my thoughts.


Everyone's opinion/voice has weight, whether you are in this comp or not :)

Quote (Donahey @ Dec 4 2022 11:00am)
random


Thanks for voting Donahey <3
Senior Moderator
Posts: 36,518
Joined: Jul 12 2008
Gold: 16,100.00
Trader: Trusted
Dec 4 2022 10:28pm
I'm a big fan of completely random, and absolutely no winner picking the next skill
(voted as such)

This post was edited by Textbook on Dec 4 2022 10:28pm
Member
Posts: 27,224
Joined: Nov 18 2013
Gold: 8,070.00
Dec 5 2022 11:06pm
Quote (Textbook @ Dec 4 2022 08:28pm)
I'm a big fan of completely random, and absolutely no winner picking the next skill
(voted as such)


Thank you for the vote :)

Still looking for more verbal insight as well from the community :thumbsup:
Member
Posts: 3,526
Joined: Mar 13 2007
Gold: 172.00
Dec 7 2022 12:41pm
Also a fan of the wheel deciding the skill each week, but would like it if overall and slayer were still consistent on a rotation of weeks ending in 5 & 10.
Member
Posts: 27,224
Joined: Nov 18 2013
Gold: 8,070.00
Dec 7 2022 01:17pm
they would be. I apologise for neglecting to say that.
Member
Posts: 11,963
Joined: Feb 23 2020
Gold: 500.00
Dec 9 2022 12:30pm
Definitely wheel spin imo. I think that’s the best for the comp instead of the winner choosing the next skill that they want to work in or whatever.
Go Back To RuneScape Topic List
12Next
Closed New Topic New Poll