d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Books & Literature > Question About The Hobbit > Pay Fg For Answer
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 41,707
Joined: Jun 29 2007
Gold: 166,159.00
Dec 18 2013 09:15pm
near the end before they enter the mountain, bilbo said he has rescued thorin twice already. i believe he was referring to the spider and wood-elf incidents. but wasn't thorin captured by the elf without being captured by the spider? so technically he was rescued only once by bilbo
am i missing something?
Member
Posts: 5,874
Joined: Aug 4 2009
Gold: 26,984.80
Dec 19 2013 10:15am
hew as refering to the first one, where he saved thorin from the orc, by dive tackling him
Member
Posts: 41,707
Joined: Jun 29 2007
Gold: 166,159.00
Dec 19 2013 11:44am
Quote (touches175 @ Dec 19 2013 09:15am)
hew as refering to the first one, where he saved thorin from the orc, by dive tackling him


i don't remember any orc indidents in this book
Member
Posts: 28,150
Joined: Aug 23 2007
Gold: 1,100.00
Dec 19 2013 11:51am
there also were not three books

:bonk:
Member
Posts: 11,747
Joined: Feb 14 2008
Gold: 23,456.00
Dec 19 2013 08:58pm
He's referring to saving them from the elves, as well as thinking quickly on his feet when they were captured by the three trolls. He used his wit to trick the trolls and assisting the their escape.
Member
Posts: 41,707
Joined: Jun 29 2007
Gold: 166,159.00
Dec 19 2013 09:40pm
Quote (LoRFate @ Dec 19 2013 07:58pm)
He's referring to saving them from the elves, as well as thinking quickly on his feet when they were captured by the three trolls. He used his wit to trick the trolls and assisting the their escape.


pretty sure that was gandalf who saved them from the trolls, not bilbo
Member
Posts: 11,747
Joined: Feb 14 2008
Gold: 23,456.00
Dec 21 2013 10:08pm
Quote (Jaliy @ Dec 19 2013 08:40pm)
pretty sure that was gandalf who saved them from the trolls, not bilbo


He stalled the trolls
Member
Posts: 41,707
Joined: Jun 29 2007
Gold: 166,159.00
Dec 21 2013 10:14pm
Quote (LoRFate @ Dec 21 2013 09:08pm)
He stalled the trolls


how did bilbo stall t he trolls?
Member
Posts: 1,849
Joined: May 31 2008
Gold: 2,571.50
Dec 28 2013 03:10am
Quote (Jaliy @ Dec 21 2013 11:14pm)
how did bilbo stall t he trolls?


Trolls turn to stone when they come in contact with the rays of the sun. Bilbo noticed that first light would peak over (blank) shortly, but not before him and his companions would become troll food. So with quick thinking he stalled the trolls by discussing different ways to cook dwarf. (if memory serves me right, has been years)

E*
I found this particular clip on youtube of the hobbit movie. Given the movie and book are different, if memory serves me right this interpretation isn't that off? Other people can comment if I'm incorrect.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A7Tw3JP-M44

This post was edited by Noobtard on Dec 28 2013 03:10am
Member
Posts: 2,595
Joined: Feb 7 2007
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 30%
Jan 10 2014 03:20am
Quote (Jaliy @ Dec 19 2013 10:40pm)
pretty sure that was gandalf who saved them from the trolls, not bilbo


in the movie that would be correct, but that was not in the book. Bilbo tricks the trolls into arguing till sunrise by imitating their voice to escalate an argument
Go Back To Books & Literature Topic List
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll