d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Books & Literature > Story Number 3, Intro > Comments Anyone? *very Short.
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 58,281
Joined: Jul 10 2006
Gold: 2,900.49
Dec 2 2009 06:25pm
Quote
  At five o’clock the big clock in the center of the office let out a loud bang which echoed magnificently over the seemingly countless number of desks and clerks. For them, the clock and its ring meant the end of the work day and offered an escape from the perpetual apathy they learned day after day.
 
  This couldn’t be truer for a young government clerk named Wilhelm. Wilhelm, a gaunt German fellow, had been a clerk at the local government post office for some 5 years. His primary task was to insure that the calls were routed to their destinations correctly. During his early days as a clerk he had a passion for the work and a respect for his post, but these virtues have long since deteriorated.
 
As a result, Wilhelm lived his life just to hear the ring of the bell. His entire day’s labor was conducted for the sole purpose of hearing the bell’s liberating cry; the monetary compensation came a distant second.
 
  The life of a clerk is a repetitiously methodical one, and Wilhelm often had a bitter laugh at the absurdity of a clerk’s existence being referred to as a “life”. To him, life meant the ability to think on his own and act on his own liberty; if he so pleased. The desolate career of clerkship allowed neither, and there was no escape to be had in the bureaucratic dungeon in which Wilhelm was confined every day.
 
  As he strolled out of the building, Wilhelm felt intoxicated. His body had left the building, but his mind remained in the mindset of the clerk. “Walk home, climb the stairs to my flat, open door, get ready for bed….” thought his mind, in a manner very much outside of his own mental autonomy.
 
And so he followed his program and began the walk home in the brisk Manhattan evening. “Perhaps when I get home I’ll read a page or two of poetry before bed…” he thought, faintly, as stood in wait on the corner for the road to clear.
 
  Wilhelm had a fine collection of books in his apartment, but had devolved beyond the point where he could appreciate them. Every night he would resolve (typically on the walk home) to rekindle his reading passion, and then; just as routine, he would abandon these thoughts. Instead he would sit in his lounge chair and gaze upon the lifeless tomes, thinking that even they, in their physical unanimity, possessed more life than he did.


Introduction to my third story. If you need more information let me know and I'll help you out. All comments and suggestions appreciated.
Member
Posts: 2,932
Joined: May 30 2009
Gold: 0.00
Dec 5 2009 12:20am
If you don't mind me saying so this is much better. This is a nice case of less is more. Yes you used a nice vocabulary but at the same time it was direct and simple. Not tedious at all. Good job :)
Member
Posts: 7,490
Joined: Jun 22 2007
Gold: 5.00
Dec 5 2009 09:56pm
id be hooked :D
Member
Posts: 58,281
Joined: Jul 10 2006
Gold: 2,900.49
Dec 6 2009 09:05pm
Quote (succulentdesire @ Dec 5 2009 06:20am)
If you don't mind me saying so this is much better. This is a nice case of less is more. Yes you used a nice vocabulary but at the same time it was direct and simple. Not tedious at all. Good job :)


Thanks for reading, you too B4K3R.

I am going to probably expand more on this one tomorrow, and I'll post here if you are interested in reading it.
Member
Posts: 2,932
Joined: May 30 2009
Gold: 0.00
Dec 7 2009 05:05pm
Quote (Kamahl16 @ Dec 6 2009 08:05pm)
Thanks for reading, you too B4K3R.

I am going to probably expand more on this one tomorrow, and I'll post here if you are interested in reading it.


please do :) hmmm... it's probably insignificant but I would change the 5 o'clock to 5 pm. the two clocks right after each other sound a little weird. but that's just a suggestion. the other thing i wanted to ask you is why you used the word unanimity. what were you trying to say?

once again please never take my comments the wrong way, I'm a little picky sometime but I really just want to help
Member
Posts: 58,281
Joined: Jul 10 2006
Gold: 2,900.49
Dec 7 2009 10:50pm
Quote (succulentdesire @ Dec 7 2009 11:05pm)
please do :) hmmm... it's probably insignificant but I would change the 5 o'clock to 5 pm. the two clocks right after each other sound a little weird. but that's just a suggestion.  the other thing i wanted to ask you is why you used the word unanimity. what were you trying to say?

once again please never take my comments the wrong way, I'm a little picky sometime but I really just want to help


I - I felt the exact thing about the two clocks so close together, I'll consider the change.

II - It lacks animation, so it cannot move and doesn't possess life.


EDIT - God damnit the word does work in that situation; I thought it wouldn't. Thanks for pointing that out, I'll re-word that part.


This post was edited by Kamahl16 on Dec 7 2009 10:51pm
Member
Posts: 18,010
Joined: Apr 8 2008
Gold: 8,653.74
Dec 8 2009 11:48pm
[/COLOR]
Quote (Kamahl16 @ Dec 7 2009 09:50pm)
[COLOR=green]I - I felt the exact thing about the two clocks so close together, I'll consider the change.

II - It lacks animation, so it cannot move and doesn't possess life.


EDIT - God damnit the word does work in that situation; I thought it wouldn't. Thanks for pointing that out, I'll re-word that part.


There are many more additional grammatical errors, including an improper semi-colon in the final paragraph, missing the word he in "thought, faintly, as stood," and the use of the word "truer" (which should be substituted with 'more true'). There are also commas missing in many places, and other minor things like placing the " before the . in (referred to as a “life”.).

To be honest, I don't like this introduction at all. It is dull, tedious to read, and very uninteresting. I understand that you're trying to portray a sense of uniform, "lifeless" boredom within your story, but your constant usage of prepositions and complex sentences removes the depth perception a work like this should have in order to catch the audience's attention.

I have no problem with a sudden exchange of narrative forms within your work. It would open an awesome perspective to the reader if we could see through the reader's eyes AND at the same time get a third person narrative scope.

That's it for now! If you need additional help, ask either succulentdesire or myself, since we share computarz and she's a little too nice for her own good.

This post was edited by onepagememory on Dec 8 2009 11:49pm
Go Back To Books & Literature Topic List
Add Reply New Topic New Poll