Quote (eriot @ Sun, Aug 31 2008, 02:37pm)
theres good potential,
some criticism i might offer cud have to do with how certain elements of the poem conflict with what seems is ur purpose
the end portion is linguistically evocative of the christian elegy but the tone of your piece is not about loss and fortitude,
but just fortitude by itself. i think you are missing a stanza to make a better (more poetic) connection between chess and life.
the elegy uses loss. thats prety powerful. give us a reason why we shud say good game. cos there is a god isnt good enuf.
if you read this out loud to yourself, you should be able to spot out all the metric errors. u probly dont care but besides just being correct,
it sounds smoother. poems of course dont need to "sound" smooth, but the repitition u use suggests this is a lyric, or meant to be heard in some way.
overall, good work. im bad at keeping a narration and using simple allegories.
its just supposed to flow in an up down meter, i have read it out loud and i think it flows rather nicely. what part do you think doesn't flow this way?
i actually considered added an extra stanza in the middle of the last, but i decided id rather it end that very specific way. i wanted it to end rather abruptly so it keeps the audience thinking. although its not supposed to be "just cus theres a god" it was supposed to just be life wont always be bad. i try to throw in a little religious reference in most, if not all of my poems.
im not really sure what linguistically evocative means, but i didn't want to spell out the connection for the audience, i wanted to resemble a more underlying theme of the poem.
i started it out in a manner that is completly independant of the ending, and worked it in as the poem goes on.
by the end of the poem, this is the messege i wished to convey: in chess, like life, there are choices that are either good or bad, and even when you think youre doing great, life throws a 180 and goes bad (when johnny loses his game) but he doesn't let it bother him, he works through it, and resets the board because he knows it will get better, and is ready to play again in a good attitude.
thanks for the input
This post was edited by Kamikizzle on Sep 4 2008 05:23pm