<DIV class="quote1">Quote (xthe_gx @ Wed, Aug 1 2007, 03:39am)</DIV><DIV class="quote2">I must admit althought the ending was quite poorly written
From begining to end..it is w/o a dought the best harry potter book ever written</DIV>

you obviously havent analyzed the story of the hero

read joseph cambell's A Hero with a Thousand Faces
you will understand why the symbolism and plot fits the stucture

was well done, too bad harry and voldemorts final dual wasnt more glorious but that wasnt the point

This post was edited by blackjack21 on Aug 4 2007 08:36pm

yes and being one of the first million to finish a book that sold millions of copys is exactly what i meant

it almost seemed like the epilogue was written when she wrote the first book, and hadnt really mastered her writing yet, as compared to the rest of the book

This post was edited by emalooser on Aug 4 2007 11:30pm

''left alot to be desired''
ya kinda like wtf happent to george? after his twin died? wtf not even a word about him and how he got along without him for the next 20 yrs

i can garuntee you that 99% of the people who got the book first night or the next day finished it within 2 days

ya, i would really like to know what happened to the weasleys, the rest of the order of the pheonix, the rest of dumbledores army (DA) and the proffessors from hogwarts, hagrid, some of the dark wizards what was done with them, a little bit of story on the rebuild of hogwarts, etc etc etc it goes on

but, still an awesome book

yeah the book was lovly but why did Frank die?

i thought the ending was awesome. but i was disappointed with the epilogue, not really waht i expected/hoped

"ya, i would really like to know what happened to the weasleys, the rest of the order of the pheonix, the rest of dumbledores army (DA) and the proffessors from hogwarts, hagrid, some of the dark wizards what was done with them, a little bit of story on the rebuild of hogwarts, etc etc etc it goes on"

i really wanted to know what would become of umbridge

This post was edited by mikem3289 on Aug 15 2007 02:11pm

i really liked it especially the ending. finally she got it to make a shorter book without long phrases.

I really want to know how the fuck Tonks and Lupin died.
This isn't about the ending.
I just want to know.