d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Books & Literature > My Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows Theory
Prev1234Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Views: 1030Replies: 31Track Topic
Member
Posts: 6,513
Joined: Mar 25 2007
Gold: 1.00
#21
Jul 17 2007 10:23am
Quote (Canadians_rulE @ Tue, Jul 10 2007, 10:42am)
Hermione dies trying to protect Ron (who dies anyway), Snape kills Hagrid, Harry's scar is the last horcrux, and to defeat Voldemort he has to kill himself. The 'Deathly Hallows' is the afterlife, and the story ends with Harry reunited with his dead friends/family.


someone posted a link on this board about a website with proof of everything thats gonna happen in the lat book. search
Member
Posts: 30,121
Joined: Oct 14 2006
Gold: 11,999.00
#22
Jul 17 2007 11:53am
Quote (Canadians_rulE @ Tue, Jul 10 2007, 02:42pm)
Hermione dies trying to protect Ron (who dies anyway), Snape kills Hagrid, Harry's scar is the last horcrux, and to defeat Voldemort he has to kill himself. The 'Deathly Hallows' is the afterlife, and the story ends with Harry reunited with his dead friends/family.


i like that theory smile.gif
Member
Posts: 2,906
Joined: May 27 2005
Gold: 347.00
#23
Jul 17 2007 07:48pm
And it isn't what happens friend has the book LOL! The ending is lame imo.
Member
Posts: 2,388
Joined: May 21 2004
Gold: 0.37
Warn: 30%
#24
Jul 18 2007 12:04pm
That theory is wrong.

Quote (TJCloutier @ Tue, Jul 17 2007, 11:23am)
Quote (Canadians_rulE @ Tue, Jul 10 2007, 10:42am)
Hermione dies trying to protect Ron (who dies anyway), Snape kills Hagrid, Harry's scar is the last horcrux, and to defeat Voldemort he has to kill himself. The 'Deathly Hallows' is the afterlife, and the story ends with Harry reunited with his dead friends/family.


someone posted a link on this board about a website with proof of everything thats gonna happen in the lat book. search

Quote
Details aren�t needed. Just say BELLATRIX KILLS RON!

That one's wrong too. Ron doesn't die.
Quote
Snape�s loyalty? I found this to be the saddest part of the book. As many people guessed, all was not what it seemed with Dumbledore, and the two did indeed have a plan that would eventually result in Snape killing him. But, Snape was only in on things for personal gain, and when Voldemort learns of this, he is obviously furious with Snape. Snape tries to make up for things by luring Harry to him, but Harry manages to escape, and Voldemort kills Snape before the final conflict.

Snape's loyalty was with Dumbledore for a very specific reason, so that strike is wrong too.
Quote
I don�t know what all these rumours are about Voldemort kidnapping Ron, it�s a complete lie. Ron is killed by Bellatrix Lestrange in The Battle of Hogwarts, but Neville manages to finish off Bellatrix after Ron weakens her before his death.

Molly kills Bellatrix, so that one's wrong too.
Quote
Harry Potter is not a horcrux.

Harry Potter is a horcrux. (p709) (I owe so many people money because of this)
Quote
Voldemort is killed in the Department Of Mysteries. He baits Harry Potter about his parents, Sirius, Dumbledore and Ron. which turns out to be the worst thing Voldemort could have done. As Voldemort steps out into the circular bit with many doors, Harry Potter opens the locked door, and Voldemort is destroyed by the blinding light, which heals Harry Potter, who seems close to death (he does not die).

Voldemort is not killed in the department of mysteries.

The door in the department of mysteries is not ever opened (to our knowledge).


This post was edited by Sharingan on Jul 18 2007 12:20pm
Member
Posts: 2,388
Joined: May 21 2004
Gold: 0.37
Warn: 30%
#25
Jul 18 2007 12:20pm
Quote
The cover art shows Voldemort + Harry Potter at the Deathly Hallows, Harry Potter is attempting to summon Voldemort�s Horcrux, as Voldemort is doing his best to keep the enchantment in place.

The Deathly Hallows != a place.
Quote
No-one loses a body part, no idea where that came from?

George loses an ear. Ch5.
Quote
Also Harry Potter does not get drunk whoever said that.

He takes firewhiskey and gets a little buzzed.
Quote
You said Ron dies so what happens to Hermy at the end?

As said, her love life isnt specified. But she becomes a Healer at St. Mungo�s.

Wrong. Dead wrong.
Quote

How�s the epilogue done?

I didn�t like it. It was in the form of a newspaper article, a sort of �Where Are They Now?� thing, 20 years on from the final showdown.

Also wrong. The epilogue is the parents (Ron, Hermione, Harry, Ginny) with their children at Platform 9 3/4.
Quote
What�s happening on the UK kids cover?

Gringotts. The trio are searching for the locket (it isnt there) but they get vital information on Ravenclaws book here.

They're not searching for the locket. Ravenclaw never had a book.
Quote
What�s Luna/Hagrid/Weasley twins/Neville�s fate?

Becomes editor of Quibbler (her dad passes it on to her)/Remains at Hogwarts to this day/Weasley�s Wizard Wheezes becomes multinational/Herbology teacher at Hogwarts after Sprout�s death (old age she isnt killed)

We don't know, no idea, Fred dies, Neville becomes herbology professor at Hogwarts.
Quote
What are the horcruxes? How does Harry Potter find and destroy them?

Nagini/Locket/Cup/Ravenclaws Book. Symbol on UK spine is a device that enables Harry Potter to locate �soul fragments� if you will, Harry Potter can destroy them a lot more easily than Dumbledore.

The correct horcruxes are: Diary (taken care of), Ring (Dumbledore took care of that), Locket, Cup, Diadem, Nagani, and (as much as it pains me to admit it), Harry.


This post was edited by Sharingan on Jul 18 2007 12:20pm
Member
Posts: 2,388
Joined: May 21 2004
Gold: 0.37
Warn: 30%
#26
Jul 18 2007 12:20pm
Quote
What�s the deal with the mirror? How does RAB and Kreacher come into the story?

Sirius has left an almost �voicemail� message on the mirror, to advise him on destroying the horcrux. Kreacher has to tell the trio (on Harry�s orders) about the history of the symbol and where to find it.

RAB took his house elf (Kreacher) to the cave, drank the potion, got sucked underwater. He made Kreacher take the amulet and destroy it (but he couldn't) and also not tell anyone what happened. The other side of the mirror (which belonged to Sirius) is stolen by Mudungus and Aberforth buys it and keeps an eye on Harry through it, sending help at times.
Quote
What�s the lies of Dumbledore chapter about?

Neon was right about this, this is to do with the plan with Snape. I don�t know if he got lucky because the Grindelwald thing isnt even close.

It's about how Dumbledore also was seeking something powerful, extreme (as well as putting muggles into their proper place. He plotted with Grindewald).
Quote
What happens to all the teachers? Who�s new headmaster etc?

McGonagall is new headmistress.

Severus Snape is the headmaster during the seventh book. We're not sure who takes over afterwards, but we can only assume McGonagall.
Quote
What�s Harry�s fate in the end? Job etc?

Becomes an almost freelance Auror but refuses to work for the MoM

Nowhere does it mention this.





That site with the spoilers is almost completely wrong.

(For the triplepost-there were too many quote marks to put into two)
Member
Posts: 390
Joined: Jul 16 2007
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 10%
#27
Jul 20 2007 11:01am
So if the scar 'is' a horcrux (which of course we know its not) then that means harry will have to CHOP OFF HIS OWN FOREHEAD! How the !&@ is he gonna get a girl then? I dont see many people w/o foreheads functioning in normal life, do you? But on a more serious note, who else thinks that the reason Snape is being bad is because he has a secret lovechild with Draco's mom? Oooo juicy! And we all pretty much know Rons gonna die (sacrifices himself in the chess game in book 1) and i forget where it says, but there was something about Ron "Proving himself to be the best of all his brothers". Also, which girl is Harry most likely to marry, assuming he lives and isn't gay? Peh theoryzor o.o
Member
Posts: 390
Joined: Jul 16 2007
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 10%
#28
Jul 22 2007 07:53pm
Quote (Dogbert @ Fri, Jul 20 2007, 10:01am)
So if the scar 'is' a horcrux (which of course we know its not) then that means harry will have to CHOP OFF HIS OWN FOREHEAD! How the !&@ is he gonna get a girl then? I dont see many people w/o foreheads functioning in normal life, do you? But on a more serious note, who else thinks that the reason Snape is being bad is because he has a secret lovechild with Draco's mom? Oooo juicy! And we all pretty much know Rons gonna die (sacrifices himself in the chess game in book 1) and i forget where it says, but there was something about Ron "Proving himself to be the best of all his brothers". Also, which girl is Harry most likely to marry, assuming he lives and isn't gay? Peh theoryzor o.o


Wrong! Harry is a horcrux (although an accidental one). And the Deathly Hallows IS NOT A PLACE! The deathly hallows are the three magical items Grindelwald and Dumbledore were gonna use to take over the world. (it sounds fishy but its true, just a strange way of wording it.)
Member
Posts: 38,069
Joined: Mar 16 2007
Gold: 312.01
Trader: Trusted
#29
Jul 22 2007 08:34pm
Guys read the book before posting more crackpot "spoilers"
Member
Posts: 390
Joined: Jul 16 2007
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 10%
#30
Jul 23 2007 02:25am
Quote (jp2050 @ Sun, Jul 22 2007, 07:34pm)
Guys read the book before posting more crackpot "spoilers"


Have "you" read the book? Because theres nothing crackpot aboot it, eh!
Go Back To Books & Literature Topic List
Prev1234Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll

© 2003-2026 d2jsp  Contact