d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Books & Literature > Hp Fans > not to worry
Prev12
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 5,271
Joined: Sep 28 2006
Gold: 0.00
Jul 29 2007 05:52pm
Quote (Ice98 @ Sun, Jul 29 2007, 05:29pm)
yea i think the whole "19 years later" bit was too much closure, i mean she could have written at least 2 more books (you could do the Dumbledores army, and follow neville and crew) and aftermath of everyones life for the next year or 2 after the defeat


She is writeing a book on everyone else's life which is supposed to include alot about Neville. But I disagree with the 19 years later part being too much the only part that disappointed me was that she didn't say what anyone's occupation was. I was really interested in Harry being Minister of Magic and Hermoninny being over hogwarts.(our atleast auror and teacher if the other was a streach lol)
Member
Posts: 27,772
Joined: May 27 2007
Gold: 5,414.01
Jul 29 2007 05:55pm
Quote (dragoncore @ Sun, Jul 29 2007, 03:52pm)
Quote (Ice98 @ Sun, Jul 29 2007, 05:29pm)
yea i think the whole "19 years later" bit was too much closure, i mean she could have written at least 2 more books (you could do the Dumbledores army, and follow neville and crew) and aftermath of everyones life for the next year or 2 after the defeat


She is writeing a book on everyone else's life which is supposed to include alot about Neville. But I disagree with the 19 years later part being too much the only part that disappointed me was that she didn't say what anyone's occupation was. I was really interested in Harry being Minister of Magic and Hermoninny being over hogwarts.(our atleast auror and teacher if the other was a streach lol)


they did say that neville became a proffessor (proffessor longbottom)

but ya, im gonna be waiting on that one!


they didnt say mutch about the other characters ya know, hagrid, the weasleys, harrys aunt and uncle, hermiones parents, the other proffessors like mcgonagal and stuff, and all those people
Member
Posts: 5,271
Joined: Sep 28 2006
Gold: 0.00
Jul 29 2007 06:00pm
neville was the only one she commented on and the least i was interested in lol

This post was edited by dragoncore on Jul 29 2007 06:01pm
Member
Posts: 27,772
Joined: May 27 2007
Gold: 5,414.01
Jul 29 2007 06:08pm
Quote (dragoncore @ Sun, Jul 29 2007, 04:00pm)
neville was the only one she commented on and the least i was interested in lol


i think its funny that neville ended up teaching about plants

i mean, both parents where aurors, his grandma obviously kicks some ass for an old lady, and hes the one that lead dumbledores army for almost a year, he had the qualitys to do something bigger IMO

he started out as a boring character,but become something of a minor hero
Member
Posts: 12,824
Joined: Jan 10 2006
Gold: 38,115.35
Jul 29 2007 07:27pm
Quote (Ice98 @ Mon, Jul 30 2007, 01:08am)
Quote (dragoncore @ Sun, Jul 29 2007, 04:00pm)
neville was the only one she commented on and the least i was interested in lol


i think its funny that neville ended up teaching about plants

i mean, both parents where aurors, his grandma obviously kicks some ass for an old lady, and hes the one that lead dumbledores army for almost a year, he had the qualitys to do something bigger IMO

he started out as a boring character,but become something of a minor hero


You think being a teacher isn't important?
Member
Posts: 15,743
Joined: Nov 17 2006
Gold: 33.00
Jul 29 2007 08:10pm
The ending was way too brisk, and the romance between Harry and Ginny was forced since book 6.

This post was edited by Nihlathak on Jul 29 2007 08:10pm
Member
Posts: 2,866
Joined: Jul 1 2005
Gold: 12.35
Jul 30 2007 09:17am
Quote (Nihlathak @ Mon, Jul 30 2007, 02:10am)
The ending was way too brisk, and the romance between Harry and Ginny was forced since book 6.


All very true....the 19 years later was just a complete throw off to the story....it should have ended at their 7th yar.

I did like how Harry named on of his children "Albus Severus", though...heart2.gif

The only thing that pissed me off is that we never found out how some choose to be ghosts or not!!! Did I just miss it??
Member
Posts: 12,824
Joined: Jan 10 2006
Gold: 38,115.35
Jul 30 2007 10:52am
I think you become a ghost if you there is something on earth that's holding you back.. If you can't accept death, that you have something unfinished on earth.. Dumbledore wouldn't become a ghost, but The bloody baron did because surely he fealt remorse, regret and guilt over his murder on the "grey lady"
Member
Posts: 27,772
Joined: May 27 2007
Gold: 5,414.01
Jul 31 2007 05:25pm
Quote (Dragon_Reborn @ Sun, Jul 29 2007, 05:27pm)
Quote (Ice98 @ Mon, Jul 30 2007, 01:08am)
Quote (dragoncore @ Sun, Jul 29 2007, 04:00pm)
neville was the only one she commented on and the least i was interested in lol


i think its funny that neville ended up teaching about plants

i mean, both parents where aurors, his grandma obviously kicks some ass for an old lady, and hes the one that lead dumbledores army for almost a year, he had the qualitys to do something bigger IMO

he started out as a boring character,but become something of a minor hero


You think being a teacher isn't important?


sure it is, but he was teaching the herbology class (or w/e its called) and while those plants helped in the big battle, i mean, i just think he coulda been an auror, or def against dark arts, or hell even minister of magic or something

but, i guess throughout the books that was what he was always best at
Member
Posts: 2,461
Joined: May 4 2006
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Aug 2 2007 11:50pm
Quote (trish7210 @ Mon, Jul 30 2007, 08:17am)
Quote (Nihlathak @ Mon, Jul 30 2007, 02:10am)
The ending was way too brisk, and the romance between Harry and Ginny was forced since book 6.


All very true....the 19 years later was just a complete throw off to the story....it should have ended at their 7th yar.

I did like how Harry named on of his children "Albus Severus", though...heart2.gif

The only thing that pissed me off is that we never found out how some choose to be ghosts or not!!! Did I just miss it??



if u paid attention in book 5 i believe after serius black dies harry comes back to school and talks to nearly headless nick and he say and dont quote me on this

that to become a ghost u have to be affraiud to cross over and actualy die and that black had no reason to be a ghost and harry is all distraut over it and then he is over it when he relizes he is actualy gone.... was kinda lame explaination they gave in the book

Quote (Ice98 @ Tue, Jul 31 2007, 04:25pm)
Quote (Dragon_Reborn @ Sun, Jul 29 2007, 05:27pm)
Quote (Ice98 @ Mon, Jul 30 2007, 01:08am)
Quote (dragoncore @ Sun, Jul 29 2007, 04:00pm)
neville was the only one she commented on and the least i was interested in lol


i think its funny that neville ended up teaching about plants

i mean, both parents where aurors, his grandma obviously kicks some ass for an old lady, and hes the one that lead dumbledores army for almost a year, he had the qualitys to do something bigger IMO

he started out as a boring character,but become something of a minor hero


You think being a teacher isn't important?


sure it is, but he was teaching the herbology class (or w/e its called) and while those plants helped in the big battle, i mean, i just think he coulda been an auror, or def against dark arts, or hell even minister of magic or something

but, i guess throughout the books that was what he was always best at


and that was his favorite subject in all the books leading up to the 7th he was best at it fumble almost all the other shit buty not that



This post was edited by insaneclown-ha on Aug 2 2007 11:52pm
Go Back To Books & Literature Topic List
Prev12
Add Reply New Topic New Poll