d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Graphic Design > Photography > Critique Please > How Could I Make This Better?
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Views: 536Replies: 12Track Topic
Member
Posts: 7,400
Joined: Jun 20 2004
Gold: 62,694.66
#1
Sep 9 2012 04:05pm
Just looking for some constructive crit on this. Kinda new to landscape.

Member
Posts: 2,372
Joined: Aug 11 2006
Gold: 163.00
#2
Sep 9 2012 04:37pm
I actually prefer the color version, but either way it's a very nice picture. It almost looks more like CG than a real photo, but I like that. =-]
Member
Posts: 7,400
Joined: Jun 20 2004
Gold: 62,694.66
#3
Sep 9 2012 04:46pm
Quote (AtomicCynic @ Sep 9 2012 10:37pm)
I actually prefer the color version, but either way it's a very nice picture. It almost looks more like CG than a real photo, but I like that. =-]


Hey thanks, yeah I thought it seemed more dramatic this way and that the clouds really came to life desaturated, I may also still try fiddling around with a better color ver.
Member
Posts: 7,400
Joined: Jun 20 2004
Gold: 62,694.66
#4
Sep 9 2012 05:11pm
Okay, here is it in color with it all straight as well.
I'm trying to reduce the "halo" around the building but its proving to be difficult!




This post was edited by Silenkiller on Sep 9 2012 05:32pm
Member
Posts: 32,538
Joined: Dec 6 2007
Gold: 1,945.00
#5
Sep 9 2012 05:48pm
Yeesh, its so HDR that it almost looks like a manip.

Say no to borders.
Member
Posts: 7,400
Joined: Jun 20 2004
Gold: 62,694.66
#6
Sep 9 2012 07:27pm
The whole point of HDR is to look HDR isnt it ;p
Member
Posts: 2,372
Joined: Aug 11 2006
Gold: 163.00
#7
Sep 9 2012 07:41pm
Quote (Silenkiller @ 10 Sep 2012 02:27)
The whole point of HDR is to look HDR isnt it ;p


Any chance you could post the original image minus the HDR? Just for a comparison?
Member
Posts: 32,538
Joined: Dec 6 2007
Gold: 1,945.00
#8
Sep 9 2012 11:34pm
Quote (Silenkiller @ Sep 9 2012 07:27pm)
The whole point of HDR is to look HDR isnt it ;p


No.

I find the best HDR images are the ones where you wonder if its HDR or not.
Member
Posts: 2,819
Joined: Oct 30 2010
Gold: 1,100.85
#9
Sep 9 2012 11:57pm
Quote (Xandriia @ Sep 10 2012 07:34am)
No.

I find the best HDR images are the ones where you wonder if its HDR or not.


i agree .

Quote (AtomicCynic @ Sep 10 2012 03:41am)
Any chance you could post the original image minus the HDR? Just for a comparison?


i dont see any point in that, we all probably know how it looks without bad hdr .
Member
Posts: 11,567
Joined: Sep 11 2008
Gold: 205.00
#10
Sep 10 2012 02:47am
Quote (Xandriia @ 10 Sep 2012 09:34)
No.

I find the best HDR images are the ones where you wonder if its HDR or not.


this

and a basic mistake is you have cut the bottom of the building off so feels like we are missing something
Go Back To Photography Topic List
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll

© 2003-2026 d2jsp  Contact