d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Graphic Design > Photography > Some Pics For A Project O.o > Rate Um O.o
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 11,944
Joined: Dec 8 2007
Gold: 0.00
Nov 4 2010 07:59pm




i barely touch to my camera once a year and naowww rate on 10? :wub: pl0x
Member
Posts: 18,010
Joined: Apr 8 2008
Gold: 8,653.74
Nov 4 2010 08:07pm
In order to rate more accurately and to give you better pointers, can you give me a description of your project?
Member
Posts: 11,944
Joined: Dec 8 2007
Gold: 0.00
Nov 4 2010 08:19pm
Quote (onepagememory @ 4 Nov 2010 22:07)
In order to rate more accurately and to give you better pointers, can you give me a description of your project?


i would if i didnt forget the description in my locker >.< :P
Member
Posts: 6,029
Joined: Sep 23 2007
Gold: 0.00
Nov 4 2010 08:45pm
Quote (ZXkarmaXZ @ Nov 4 2010 07:19pm)
i would if i didnt forget the description in my locker >.< :P


Facepalm.
Member
Posts: 42,679
Joined: Aug 2 2007
Gold: 8.00
Warn: 30%
Nov 7 2010 06:12am
ideas are good but quality of pics is not on it's best :/
Member
Posts: 3,373
Joined: Dec 2 2006
Gold: 0.56
Nov 7 2010 07:14am
Looks like I took those pictures.
Member
Posts: 3,721
Joined: Mar 9 2009
Gold: 18,282.74
Nov 7 2010 08:56am
I like #2 the most, though I think it would've looked better if the focus was more in the foreground.
Member
Posts: 3,996
Joined: Oct 2 2008
Gold: 20.46
Nov 7 2010 10:12am
All of these are, firstly, over sized. It's annoying having to shrink the window to view them at an enjoyable size. (That's coming from a 24")
Each of these are all lacking one major thing, a subject, a theme, something exciting that draws are attention.
Sure, you showed me you know how to use the aperture and get some DoF, but you failed to make the shutter speed work with it to keep the entire thing in an even exposure. (The sky in the first - it's brutally white!)

The ground isn't an enjoyable subject. As humans, we're drawn to like warm, dry, beautiful tones. A photo of a mucky wet dry road, is not the kinda' thing I want to look at more than once.
With your framing, you don't manage to hold the camera straight. Holding the camera on an angle, it something teen girls do taking mirror pictures for Facebook - don't do it if it doesn't work! (Again, - if it doesn't work.. and it definitely doesn't here)

I don't really know the theme of your project, so I can't say much about that, how you managed to forget the sheet at school yet still know what you shot for boggles my mind.
The last one would be the most pleasing shot here in my opinion, only because of that sunburst you managed to capture.
The tree flows vertically, and although you shot vertically with it (good) to still failed to crop a pleasing scene. The stop sign is good, but because of how detailed the tree is in the background,
our eyes flow up with it - into a dead end!

I feel you either used the P mode, or the Auto mode on a cheaper point-and-shoot camera, while these may not be bad modes to use when still learning, I feel you could have definitely worked
more creatively with what you had.
That in mind, I would suggest trying to play around with the settings and modes, the stop sign would be a great shot if the background was out of focus. It would create some gorgeous tones, and some bokeh that everybody loves.
Also, keep that car out of the frame! I don't want to see half a car in a shot with great potential of expressing some beautiful fall tones.

-Spencer
Member
Posts: 18,010
Joined: Apr 8 2008
Gold: 8,653.74
Nov 7 2010 10:31am
Quote (TheBlackRose66 @ Nov 7 2010 09:12am)
All of these are, firstly, over sized. It's annoying having to shrink the window to view them at an enjoyable size. (That's coming from a 24")
Each of these are all lacking one major thing, a subject, a theme, something exciting that draws are attention.
Sure, you showed me you know how to use the aperture and get some DoF, but you failed to make the shutter speed work with it to keep the entire thing in an even exposure. (The sky in the first - it's brutally white!)

The ground isn't an enjoyable subject. As humans, we're drawn to like warm, dry, beautiful tones. A photo of a mucky wet dry road, is not the kinda' thing I want to look at more than once.
With your framing, you don't manage to hold the camera straight. Holding the camera on an angle, it something teen girls do taking mirror pictures for Facebook - don't do it if it doesn't work! (Again, - if it doesn't work.. and it definitely doesn't here)

I don't really know the theme of your project, so I can't say much about that, how you managed to forget the sheet at school yet still know what you shot for boggles my mind.
The last one would be the most pleasing shot here in my opinion, only because of that sunburst you managed to capture.
The tree flows vertically, and although you shot vertically with it (good) to still failed to crop a pleasing scene. The stop sign is good, but because of how detailed the tree is in the background,
our eyes flow up with it - into a dead end!

I feel you either used the P mode, or the Auto mode on a cheaper point-and-shoot camera, while these may not be bad modes to use when still learning, I feel you could have definitely worked
more creatively with what you had.
That in mind, I would suggest trying to play around with the settings and modes, the stop sign would be a great shot if the background was out of focus. It would create some gorgeous tones, and some bokeh that everybody loves.
Also, keep that car out of the frame! I don't want to see half a car in a shot with great potential of expressing some beautiful fall tones.

-Spencer


Oh my god... are you feeling well? You're being helpful? <3
Member
Posts: 3,996
Joined: Oct 2 2008
Gold: 20.46
Nov 7 2010 11:20am
Quote (onepagememory @ Nov 7 2010 04:31pm)
Oh my god... are you feeling well? You're being helpful? <3


Meh, seeing as not many others are..
Go Back To Photography Topic List
Add Reply New Topic New Poll