d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Graphic Design > Photography > Polarizing Filter
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 25,533
Joined: May 8 2007
Gold: 3,720.00
May 9 2010 05:43am
Any brand to avoid?
I look online at local photo stores, and they all go for over 100$..
I really can't afford this...
So I looked at the eeebay thingy hoping to find something..
But I get lost with all the different ones..
Some are selling for 10$, some others around 55$ and I still have to look them all..

Some of the brands I see are Hoya, Zeikos, KENKO, etc..

Anyone knows if there is a big difference?
What brand should I avoid?
I don't want to pay 100$ cause I can't affort it, seriously, but I can't affort to pay 10$ either if it's going to ruin my pictures and end up in the garbage...

your input is greatly appreciated :hug:

edit..
omfg...

What the hell is the difference between circular and linear and digital polarizer filters??? :o

This post was edited by MotherOfTwo on May 9 2010 05:50am
Member
Posts: 18,010
Joined: Apr 8 2008
Gold: 8,653.74
May 9 2010 07:48am
Quote (MotherOfTwo @ May 9 2010 04:43am)
Any brand to avoid?
I look online at local photo stores, and they all go for over 100$..
I really can't afford this...
So I looked at the eeeeebay thingy hoping to find something..
But I get lost with all the different ones..
Some are selling for 10$, some others around 55$ and I still have to look them all..

Some of the brands I see are Hoya, Zeikos, KENKO, etc..

Anyone knows if there is a big difference?
What brand should I avoid?
I don't want to pay 100$ cause I can't affort it, seriously, but I can't affort to pay 10$ either if it's going to ruin my pictures and end up in the garbage...

your input is greatly appreciated :hug:

edit..
omfg...

What the hell is the difference between circular and linear and digital polarizer filters??? :o


Both have the same effect visually, which is to darken skies, fix reflections, contrast clouds, help with water shine, etc. Usually, circular polarizers don't interfere with auto functions. Both lower your light intake by 1/2, 1, or even 2-3 stops depending on the darkness.

If you have more than one lens, you may need different sizes because polarizers depend on your lens diameter. Use your manual to determine this.

In summary, if you use auto focus, just get circular as long as you can afford it and find a good deal.

I can tell you which polarizers I use on Monday when I go to work. Can't remember names.

This post was edited by onepagememory on May 9 2010 07:50am
Member
Posts: 25,533
Joined: May 8 2007
Gold: 3,720.00
May 9 2010 08:02am
Quote (onepagememory @ 9 May 2010 09:48)
Both have the same effect visually, which is to darken skies, fix reflections, contrast clouds, help with water shine, etc. Usually, circular polarizers don't interfere with auto functions. Both lower your light intake by 1/2, 1, or even 2-3 stops depending on the darkness.

If you have more than one lens, you may need different sizes because polarizers depend on your lens diameter. Use your manual to determine this.

In summary, if you use auto focus, just get circular as long as you can afford it and find a good deal.

I can tell you which polarizers I use on Monday when I go to work. Can't remember names.


Thanks :)
I only have one lens (the one that came with the camera) and it need 58 mm diameter...

Found a Hoya circular polarizing at 48% + tax and it's on my way from work to home..

I am kinda hesitant with the very cheap ones on eebay....
Member
Posts: 6,029
Joined: Sep 23 2007
Gold: 0.00
May 9 2010 10:27am
All of my filters are Hoya or Quantaray. Never have had an issue.
Member
Posts: 5,173
Joined: May 21 2006
Gold: 3,116.00
May 9 2010 12:29pm
I'd like to weigh in ... let's say you buy a nice lens. Or let's say you make money in photography. Your lens is as good as the filter you put over it. So you have a great lens and buy a crappy filter and therefore waste whatever you spent.

But not everyone will agree with this. It is logical from a certain view.

But I have some experience in the area. I've used Tiffen, Hoya, Kenko, B+W and some generic off brand polarizers. Roughly half a dozen different brands since I started photography around 1990 or so. I can say that the best you can afford is what I would pay for.

If you upgrade your lens or lenses some day but find you forked out 30-50 for a decent average filter then perhaps at that time you will have to buy another that is better whereby you can get the full or fuller resolve out of the lens.

Today, I still have a wife collection of mostly Hoya and Tiffen filters but for polarizers I use the B+W, in fact most of my filters are leaning toward B+W because I can TELL the difference in optical quality, ease of spin, AND strength of the polarization. They aren't all made equal.

So my only word of advice is, avoid off-brands, buy better brands, as close to what you can afford.
Member
Posts: 18,010
Joined: Apr 8 2008
Gold: 8,653.74
May 9 2010 02:54pm
Quote (Solarves @ May 9 2010 11:29am)
I'd like to weigh in ... let's say you buy a nice lens. Or let's say you make money in photography. Your lens is as good as the filter you put over it. So you have a great lens and buy a crappy filter and therefore waste whatever you spent.

But not everyone will agree with this. It is logical from a certain view.

But I have some experience in the area. I've used Tiffen, Hoya, Kenko, B+W and some generic off brand polarizers. Roughly half a dozen different brands since I started photography around 1990 or so. I can say that the best you can afford is what I would pay for.

If you upgrade your lens or lenses some day but find you forked out 30-50 for a decent average filter then perhaps at that time you will have to buy another that is better whereby you can get the full or fuller resolve out of the lens.

Today, I still have a wife collection of mostly Hoya and Tiffen filters but for polarizers I use the B+W, in fact most of my filters are leaning toward B+W because I can TELL the difference in optical quality, ease of spin, AND strength of the polarization. They aren't all made equal.

So my only word of advice is, avoid off-brands, buy better brands, as close to what you can afford.


This. I started with taped-on, home made colored plastic filter attempts just to see if I could get a decent sky and not have to spend money.
Member
Posts: 17,788
Joined: Sep 15 2007
Gold: 20.00
May 10 2010 04:38pm
BOO to Hoya. I bought one of their polarizing filters and the glass was not even properly attached to the ring around it so you can like shift it back and forth now -_-

I'm a fan of B+W but it's quite an expensive brand. High quality filters though.
Go Back To Photography Topic List
Add Reply New Topic New Poll