hmmmmm I think the best thing about roses are their colors

Not when they're withered. He's trying to portray that in these images, I think. At any rate, red, withered roses get this beautiful violet-red color, so it may still be considered a waste.

They see quite noisy?
Some petals seem over exposed, and then some others seem under exposed.
Lacks composition in my opinion, doesn't catch my eye or grab my attention.
Also wondering about the black change in the 2nd picture on the bottom of the frame.
Cropped, then placed on a vertical background??? Colors don't match? Not sure.

Yep, imo b&w gives nice atmosphere to them when withered, and these one didnt get nice color.



Raged much?

Yes i had to use 2500iso, but little noise gives nice atmosphere with b&w on withered flowers. Your or my monitor has gotten out of calibration if you see overexposed flowers or black shade changing. Most likely mine because so long till i last time calibrated.

Try adding 1/3rd's grid over the pic if it helps you see composition.

Raged? How so?
I disagree with noise adding atmosphere. Noise is the presence of speckles in the photo, which takes away detail making it less interesting.
Shoot 100iso with a tripod.

you tend to get raged when people dont say only nice things to you. and now your just pulling shit out of your ass, because you think that i did it to you and you try to prove some point to me, thats really only in your head. i know that i could have used tripod and 100 iso. clean image isnt allways the best solution when u create atmosphere and atmosphere is really important to picture, thats if your using you extraverted intuition enough when examining pictures, but i doubt that you got eny idea about deep stuff like that or do you?

This post was edited by Antichrist- on Nov 2 2009 07:46pm

Pulling words out of your ass....Had the edit the entire fuckin' thing just to understand it.



I notice high noise, I think it makes the picture bad, boring,and unappealing.
The harsh shadows on some of the petals lower down the stems makes them underexposed, which makes the noise even more visible and deterring.

This post was edited by TheBlackRose66 on Nov 2 2009 07:53pm

They are cool - you got the right atmosphere to them. They seem to be the type that you can edit it and put words on it, sort of thing.



Hey how do you calibrate your monitor? I think mine has some darkness issues (photos appear more dark than what they really are).



That was the atmosphere he was going for. Maybe he wanted that much noise. Whether you like it or not is another thing :S

This post was edited by chantal7 on Nov 2 2009 07:55pm

Spyder 3.