Quote (Antichrist- @ Nov 2 2010 07:53pm)
if you are assigned to shoot something in particular way you gotta do so, no matter what side of the industry you are. its just that on some sides of the industry you arent gives so strict rules of how to shoot the assignment
Frankly, no.
The only type of client that's going to be strict about the way something is, is a client with experience on the subject.
If you explain something concisely to a client, and explain to them why you'd want to change something, most will listen. Arguably, clients with more money are going to be looking for creatives that push the envelope, not people that can conform to certain styles.
If you're comfortable just doing exactly what the client asks, without trying to suggest better options, when better options exist , frankly, I think you're just being mediocre, doing that is no way to grow as a creative individual, and isn't a way of thinking that should be encouraged.
Quote (Antichrist- @ Nov 2 2010 08:20pm)
lol
a change in position of an object with respect to time. lets analyze this sentence a little.
time in this case means the exposure time, and change in position of an object in this exposure time is what causes motion blur in a picture.
so how exactly are you going to capture a change in objects movement inside shutter speed without creating a motion blur?
what comes to that motion blur on #4, yes there is a barely noticeable amount of motion blur on the wings, but the picture itself doesent represent motion. if you go to a photography school this is the first thing they teach you about how to do your assignments
Again, I disagree, the implication of motion is more important than the motion itself. Whether you imply the motion through panning, through a long exposure, through strobing, etc, is irrelevant. Freezing motion is just as valid a technique as those I've just listed before, and can be even more important depending on what you're trying to shoot.
Quote (Antichrist- @ Nov 2 2010 08:36pm)
#4 and #12 would fall into theme catching the moment, thats the exact opposite of motion. im not complaining about pictures or the theme, im just saying that if there is a theme, people should follow it.
whats the point of even having a theme unless people dont post pictures that fit the theme and are still allowed to participate?
Having a theme is good, but having a theme that gives people creative possibilities is even better. Your kind of thinking is exactly what hinders real creativity. There are many "rules" in photography, and I'd argue that knowing when to break them is far more important than knowing the rule itself.
Quote (Antichrist- @ Nov 2 2010 11:15pm)
sorry i take back some of what i said. you dont need to have motion blur to show motion if you flash your strobe multiple times like this:
http://people.rit.edu/andpph/photofile-misc/strobe-motion-ta-08.jpg
now im starting to feel that you are just fucking with me. explain what part of all of this you dont understand or ill just assume that you are playing dumb
Honestly dude, I think you're just not particularly well educated on the subject.
Keep an open mind, study more on the subject and continue to grow, don't let yourself be blinkered by certain ways of thinking.