Rate The Photo Above You - Topic

0me

Member

Posts: 28,500

Joined: Jun 26 2006

Gold: 9,163.90

Trader: Trusted

#601

Feb 21 2011 11:36am

Quote (Terrible_One @ Feb 21 2011 04:45pm)

7/10 - The highlights add a lot of depth to the image but the other tones are a little muted. It might also be better if you made the horizon parallel to the photo's edge.

http://farm6.static.flickr.com/5259/5407584433_c8e3800cc2.jpg

E- 5x4 large format

I like the composition and the light, but i don't like the postproduction on his skin.
6.5/10

I prefer bw on this one but i'll post both versions:

Xandriia

Member

Posts: 32,538

Joined: Dec 6 2007

Gold: 1,945.00

#602

Feb 21 2011 12:00pm

Quote (Verdena @ Feb 21 2011 11:36am)

I like the composition and the light, but i don't like the postproduction on his skin.
6.5/10

I prefer bw on this one but i'll post both versions:

http://farm6.static.flickr.com/5178/5465623462_debe28341b_b.jpg

http://img502.imageshack.us/img502/3096/eaglec.jpg

The framing and birds expression is nice, but I dont like this very much for a couple reasons. First, the bokeh is much too extreme (and generally I love bokeh). Im assuming you were pretty close to a fence when you took this?

The bw is worse than the color because it makes the front of the bird look even more overexposed, and the contrast is kind of gross to be honest. Needs more blacks. Colored versions colors are very dull, and again his front is too bright :x

Now maybe I can get a comment on mine, since I never fail to get skipped when I post in here xD