d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Graphic Design > Photography > Motion Contest Voting Thread. > Nov. 1 To Nov. 8th
Prev15678914Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 29,057
Joined: Aug 3 2005
Gold: 13.37
Nov 2 2010 01:20pm
Quote (SeaBas @ 2 Nov 2010 22:12)
Oh man.. that's not true at all. A picture doesn't have to be motion blurred to display motion. @_@. Not at all.

Number 4 even has motion blur! -_-


lol

a change in position of an object with respect to time. lets analyze this sentence a little.

time in this case means the exposure time, and change in position of an object in this exposure time is what causes motion blur in a picture.

so how exactly are you going to capture a change in objects movement inside shutter speed without creating a motion blur?

what comes to that motion blur on #4, yes there is a barely noticeable amount of motion blur on the wings, but the picture itself doesent represent motion. if you go to a photography school this is the first thing they teach you about how to do your assignments
Member
Posts: 17,788
Joined: Sep 15 2007
Gold: 20.00
Nov 2 2010 01:28pm
Quote (Antichrist- @ Nov 2 2010 07:20pm)
lol

a change in position of an object with respect to time. lets analyze this sentence a little.

time in this case means the exposure time, and change in position of an object in this exposure time is what causes motion blur in a picture.

so how exactly are you going to capture a change in objects movement inside shutter speed without creating a motion blur?

what comes to that motion blur on #4, yes there is a barely noticeable amount of motion blur on the wings, but the picture itself doesent represent motion. if you go to a photography school this is the first thing they teach you about how to do your assignments


If you seriously try to tell me number 4 and 12 are not motion.. I don't feel like taking your comment seriously. Why do we need this childish complaining about the theme and what is good and bad about photos? If you don't like a picture, don't vote for it, and if you like one, vote! :)

Enough talking, we're only making it hard for the counter.

I'll vote #12 btw.
Member
Posts: 29,057
Joined: Aug 3 2005
Gold: 13.37
Nov 2 2010 01:36pm
Quote (SeaBas @ 2 Nov 2010 22:28)
If you seriously try to tell me number 4 and 12 are not motion.. I don't feel like taking your comment seriously. Why do we need this childish complaining about the theme and what is good and bad about photos? If you don't like a picture, don't vote for it, and if you like one, vote! :)

Enough talking, we're only making it hard for the counter.

I'll vote #12 btw.


#4 and #12 would fall into theme catching the moment, thats the exact opposite of motion. im not complaining about pictures or the theme, im just saying that if there is a theme, people should follow it.

whats the point of even having a theme unless people dont post pictures that fit the theme and are still allowed to participate?
Member
Posts: 10,634
Joined: Nov 19 2005
Gold: 506.04
Nov 2 2010 02:45pm
you can still express motion with a freez photo
[img]http://byfiles.storage.live.com/y1pY46w-BsHlDAgJs82N5Yg_VsPtWFGq1Ld1jlZOdKrhUDXPbbZrHccMfcxho_UoIfBByQQdQBihTw[/img]
Member
Posts: 15,477
Joined: Mar 22 2007
Gold: 13.37
Nov 2 2010 02:45pm
#11
Member
Posts: 2,560
Joined: May 6 2004
Gold: 0.79
Nov 2 2010 03:02pm
Quote (SeaBas @ Nov 2 2010 02:28pm)
If you seriously try to tell me number 4 and 12 are not motion.. I don't feel like taking your comment seriously. Why do we need this childish complaining about the theme and what is good and bad about photos? If you don't like a picture, don't vote for it, and if you like one, vote! :)

Enough talking, we're only making it hard for the counter.

I'll vote #12 btw.


Antichrist- gets real butt hurt about just about everything these days. I just try to ignore him.

I vote #4 cus I like birds

This post was edited by bountiehunter on Nov 2 2010 03:04pm
Member
Posts: 29,057
Joined: Aug 3 2005
Gold: 13.37
Nov 2 2010 03:29pm
Quote (bountiehunter @ 3 Nov 2010 00:02)
Antichrist- gets real butt hurt about just about everything these days. I just try to ignore him.

I vote #4 cus I like birds


no u!

im not hurt, im just trying to explain things to people that they dont seem to understand. yes it gets quite annoying when people fail to realize simple things even when you explain them in a way that shouldnt leave any misunderstandings, but i dont get butt hurt about it, ill just try to explain it again in another way in case they would get it when explained that way

Quote (Furia-az @ 2 Nov 2010 23:45)
you can still express motion with a freez photo
http://byfiles.storage.live.com/y1pY46w-BsHlDAgJs82N5Yg_VsPtWFGq1Ld1jlZOdKrhUDXPbbZrHccMfcxho_UoIfBByQQdQBihTw


thats again catching the moment, instead showing motion
Member
Posts: 17,788
Joined: Sep 15 2007
Gold: 20.00
Nov 2 2010 03:31pm
Quote (Antichrist- @ Nov 2 2010 09:29pm)
no u!

im not hurt, im just trying to explain things to people that they dont seem to understand. yes it gets quite annoying when people fail to realize simple things even when you explain them in a way that shouldnt leave any misunderstandings, but i dont get butt hurt about it, ill just try to explain it again in another way in case they would get it when explained that way



thats again catching the moment, instead showing motion


If you don't want stuff to be frozen, go buy yourself a video camera. -_-

This post was edited by SeaBas on Nov 2 2010 03:31pm
Member
Posts: 29,057
Joined: Aug 3 2005
Gold: 13.37
Nov 2 2010 04:15pm
Quote (SeaBas @ 3 Nov 2010 00:31)
If you don't want stuff to be frozen, go buy yourself a video camera. -_-


sorry i take back some of what i said. you dont need to have motion blur to show motion if you flash your strobe multiple times like this:



now im starting to feel that you are just fucking with me. explain what part of all of this you dont understand or ill just assume that you are playing dumb
Member
Posts: 28,500
Joined: Jun 26 2006
Gold: 9,163.90
Trader: Trusted
Nov 2 2010 04:34pm
Quote (Antichrist- @ Nov 2 2010 04:48pm)
doesent look like that imo, look closer

imo 3, 4, 5, 8, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14 and 15 doesent fit in the motion theme. if this was a school project all of those would get auto fail, no matter how good shots they are. thats like being hired to go to shoot a rally contest for a paper and you bring a picture of a rabbit on a race track to your client.

imo you should be more strict about pictures actually fitting the theme next time


Well that is your idea.
I have a different idea of motion.
It's kinda subjective imo.
Go Back To Photography Topic List
Prev15678914Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll