Can you justify your rating? I did nothing special to the eyes

ok maybe I don't like shot that much but I like preset u used for this pic.
girl eyes looks sweet, clear and scare, like she was askin wtf are they doing to me
what occasion that was ?

Here is another pic i toke in hospital early today with my iphone had to make few corrections

Wasn't a preset either. Just a desaturation with 12000 yellow white balance and 3 on blacks

Not posting a pic but just a comment.. oversharpened!!

iphone 3gs sucks hard even in good light ;-)

Enough has been said. Startin it over:



Mom's poodles just had puppies last night. Who can deny this rat?

I have no clue what is it but damn mate it's so sweet I could eat it
Great job ! 8/10

I feel this shot has incredible incredible potential. A lot of users post photos of their car on here, and honestly, they're quite boring.
However, I'm actually really diggin' the perspective this is shot. I know I've seen it before, but this could really be something incredible.
My reasoning behind this is the emotion. The domestic house cat's emotion, in this case, curiosity of the outside, or whatever it is looking so concentrated at, is something the viewer can relate to.
The way the ears point forward is great, however, I feel it would be even more dramatic and powerful if the one ear was in the frame.
The exposure is pretty good, however, I would love to see a sharper image. This would be done with a higher aperture number, which would result in greater detail and an overall "sharper" image.

Now, here's what's killing me, and I'm sure it must have crossed you mind when you took it?
That blade of grass. It seems obvious, but if not, I'll pretend to understand you wanting some "depth of fieldy' mysterious bokehy" picture.
That's a killer for me. The eyes are the main focal point of this, and the eyes on this car are incredible.
I want MORE detail in those deep eyes that the cat's using to stare so sternly at.
If you fixed that green blade of grass/plant, I feel this could be an easy 7-8/10, but right now I'd go around 3-4/10.

just a cat photo to me 5/10

I have no idea what kind of border it is in the upper border of this picture, but I don't like it, also the silhouette is badly composed imo.

3/10