Quote (Antichrist- @ Dec 26 2010 02:55pm)

dunno really how i feel about this. would be better if you had cropped out some from the top, but otherwise it looks good, but not very interesting. ill give it 7.5/10


http://farm6.static.flickr.com/5009/5292837613_4438e96a3e_b.jpg

Quote (prosnow @ Dec 26 2010 01:33pm)

9/10

Like the lighting/Tone of the picture, creeps me out too! ^_^..



http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4090/5049110281_457a842676_b.jpg

Quote (onepagememory @ Dec 27 2010 02:32am)

3/10. I apologize for being so harsh, but I will at least justify myself:

-4 points for composition / creativity.
This is the oldest pose in the wedding repeirtore. It's so overused it's not even interesting anymore. I don't understand if you made them both close their eyes or simply caught a bad moment where they both did it. If you did it on purpose, I don't see it adding an artistic effect.
The composition is akward. I would've moved more to the left to get them to look a bit closer and golden ruled' them. 3/4th's on the girl and missing the feet of the guy isn't the best view you could have provided. Try to use the pillars to your advantage. The area in between the pillars is blown out and only serves as a distraction.

-3 points on the woman's stomach
The woman's stomach is the definition of unflattering. Is she pregnant? If so, I would've fixed her shirt to promote the roundness of a pregnant belly. It looks misshapen. If she's not pregnant, then that's just carelessness from your part. The stomach was the first thing I looked at.

I'm neutral on the post processing. Women like this sort of effect, and it looks like one of the present LR3 has.

+2 points on effectively focusing on the woman and the location. Her pants / belly look sharp, and her face is just a bit off to hide any imperfections. The location offers very flattering lighting, and the sun hitting her hair provides a lovely ethereal look. If she's pregnant, I'd have shot a portrait of her there. In fact, i'd have removed the guy completely (since no one gives a damn about men in photos) and just shot her.

Good luck!

Since we're showing people (and pregnant woman, if applicable above), here's my try:

http://i364.photobucket.com/albums/oo85/LeonLeon123/HectorAlePark-97.jpg

Quote (DisconnectYourBrain @ Dec 27 2010 01:51pm)

6/10 took me a bit to understand that there is a man behind her.
here mine

http://img341.imageshack.us/img341/5967/imgp0589.jpg

Quote (PANAM @ 2 Jan 2011 10:55)

i like this one

8/10

http://img253.imageshack.us/img253/715/bdg6.jpg

Quote (hestJaevel @ Jan 2 2011 07:40pm)

Nice colors, nice reflection, but the composition in itself isn't that interesting!

6/10

http://images4.bilddagboken.se/46/_u8/_u4/_u3/_u2/_u5/u843256/f/o/e95666008af72d3614fd116423511d5e75964a7ad90be747d94a2dc7d8df0d3d.jpg

Quote (PANAM @ 3 Jan 2011 01:30)

like the colors
on the left sunshine on the right cold winter luv it ! 6/10

http://img220.imageshack.us/img220/9909/bdg5.jpg
same building difo angel, maybe better
LR3 ofc few corrections

Quote (jayandnix @ Jan 3 2011 05:25am)

3/10
sorry for being so harsh, but i really dont like it
the distortion, alignment, grain, b&w all put me off
i far preferred the previous pic


my 1st pic to be rated:
please state, what and why you you like/dislike about it
there is a lot i dont like about the pic, just want to see if i see/feel the same way you do

http://i52.tinypic.com/jg1qo7.jpg

Quote (kratos @ Jan 3 2011 11:23am)

3/10

Like the idea, however it was poorly presented. The subject is centered and somewhat of an eye sore with all of those reflections and harsh glares..

http://farm6.static.flickr.com/5168/5316690213_fb4b172887_z.jpg

My money seems to be fading away..

Quote (PANAM @ 3 Jan 2011 15:05)

money talks ! 7/10 ;-)

http://img411.imageshack.us/img411/6666/bdg1v.jpg