6 for good shoot but 1 for brightness on that scarf :-/

The contrast between the scarf and her face/hair is what makes the photo good imo.
But that could just be my point of view

meh i just don't really see anything that interesting.. 4/10

Cool pic 7/10

are those photoshop eyes? I think so, because that blue / teal is far too constant in her eyes. might be wrong. anyways, the shot itself isn´t really all that interesting. looks like a simple snapshot of a child.

This is a very recent actor's photo shoot. Anyone can guess who and what this shot is modeled after? FG Reward if guessed correctly by the midnight on the 26th.
Sorry for quality of shot, photobucket + 8% quality from LR3

This post was edited by onepagememory on Dec 25 2010 02:53am

no critics for mine?

lol im' so sorry I did write it but i guess i must've accidentally erased it.
Composition: 4/7. When doing photography as this (especially when it is 100% candid), you try to mantain composition on the subject focused since the off-focus becomes negative space. I do this a lot in weddings.
Creativity: 5/5. This is what I see when eating with someone at an elongated table, the woman's perspective. Candles make it very romantic. There's a darker interpretation as well, because of the dark eye sockets.
Quality: I can only guess what kind of lighting you used, but the darkened eye sockets really reduce the image to be rated largely on just the creativity. I'd appreciate a little bit more on the 'blacks' but that's just my taste. Unless of course you want to go for a more somber look: something like the viewer is tied up to a chair or something. The guy's expression helps this too.

dunno really how i feel about this. would be better if you had cropped out some from the top, but otherwise it looks good, but not very interesting. ill give it 7.5/10

well actually we were sitting at the table for christmas, and I had only the canlde light + some indirect lamp from above. pretty hard light conditions.