Rate The Photo Above You - Topic

0me

Member

Posts: 28,500

Joined: Jun 26 2006

Gold: 9,163.90

Trader: Trusted

#351

Nov 25 2010 08:09am

Quote (RecoveryChannel @ Nov 25 2010 02:12pm)

hmmmm I looked at it for quite a while now and I´m still not sure wether the right hand of hers distracts me or adds to the picture. it seems like it´s kinda supporting the heading and therefore belongs to the composition, but on then again it anoys me. I´d also love to see abit more sharpness. guess you shot it pretty much wide open so the area of sharpness is rather small. I assume you wanted it to be like that, but to me it´d be interesting to see the whole face sharp.

6/10

had to shoot photos of the new 5th grade pupils at my school today. boring as fuck. anyway, it turned out this test shot was pretty decent looking.

http://upload.pure34.com/upload/school-stairs2.jpg

Why you didn't fix the distortion in ps?
Anyway doesn't seem interesting to me, 5/10.

Reposting cause quality sucked.

RecoveryChannel

Member

Posts: 1,681

Joined: Aug 26 2009

Gold: 2,578.37

#352

Nov 25 2010 08:13am

Quote (Verdena @ Nov 25 2010 04:09pm)

Why you didn't fix the distortion in ps?
Anyway doesn't seem interesting to me, 5/10.

Reposting cause quality sucked.

http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4133/5159039504_de2a871fed_z.jpg

my eyes seem to suck. I fail to get it right

Glenwin

Member

Posts: 2,022

Joined: Jul 28 2010

Gold: 6.70

#353

Nov 26 2010 01:56am

Quote (ace07 @ Nov 13 2010 10:34am)

http://img241.imageshack.us/img241/2818/lake1r.jpg

insancely epic shot

RecoveryChannel

Member

Posts: 1,681

Joined: Aug 26 2009

Gold: 2,578.37

#354

Nov 26 2010 04:36am

Quote (Verdena @ Nov 25 2010 04:09pm)

Why you didn't fix the distortion in ps?
Anyway doesn't seem interesting to me, 5/10.

Reposting cause quality sucked.

http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4133/5159039504_de2a871fed_z.jpg

I think I rated the hq version already via flickr. looks pretty cool as I said, but nothing stunning. some smoke could have spiced it up, but that would have required a dark background. 7/10

AlPi

Member

Posts: 16,271

Joined: Sep 19 2005

Gold: 4,420.32

#355

Nov 26 2010 06:29am

Quote (RecoveryChannel @ 26 Nov 2010 12:36)

I think I rated the hq version already via flickr. looks pretty cool as I said, but nothing stunning. some smoke could have spiced it up, but that would have required a dark background. 7/10

http://fc08.deviantart.net/fs71/f/2010/329/c/a/ca2ee6543d9e79790fc23a2b07f8218b-d33leew.jpg

Amazing light

I tried several times to achieve such an effect, and regularly failed.

As a curiosity, I'd like to see your picture with a shorter DoF.

8/10 IMO.

ace07

Member

Posts: 17,322

Joined: Apr 29 2007

Gold: 26.00

#356

Nov 26 2010 07:08am

Quote (AlPi @ 26 Nov 2010 13:29)

Amazing light

I tried several times to achieve such an effect, and regularly failed.

As a curiosity, I'd like to see your picture with a shorter DoF.

8/10 IMO.

http://i51.tinypic.com/2i7vak3.jpg

The lower part of the photo looks like a beautiful drawing, which I like very much. I also like the soft touch of the clouds and the smoke + fog. I think this picture looks good as it is. 8/10.

Here is mine, taken with my old Olympus SP 560 UZ bridge camera:

0me

Member

Posts: 28,500

Joined: Jun 26 2006

Gold: 9,163.90

Trader: Trusted

#357

Dec 3 2010 01:27pm

Nothing interesting to me + looks low quality, 5/10

MotherOfTwo

Member

Posts: 25,530

Joined: May 8 2007

Gold: 3,720.00

#358

Dec 3 2010 02:14pm

Quote (Verdena @ 3 Dec 2010 14:27)

Nothing interesting to me + looks low quality, 5/10

http://farm6.static.flickr.com/5003/5229187863_5c5efdaa22.jpg

Hmm.... for once I can see a complete picture cause on Flickr (I can't see those on imageshack or stuff like that)
But I can't say I like it...

It is too dark, the face has no light on it, and I am extremely distracted by the line between the wall and floor...
Your model has such a pretty smile, but the eye is drawn to the white shirt and the hands....
I'm sorry but I can't give more than a 2/10 :cry:

Here's mine...
It's an older picture I dug from July 2009 when I still had my Powershot..
Well, I still have it but don't use it...

BebebBurns

Member

Posts: 29,218

Joined: Nov 15 2010

Gold: 7.69

#359

Dec 4 2010 12:58am

Quote (MotherOfTwo @ Dec 3 2010 10:14pm)

Hmm.... for once I can see a complete picture cause on Flickr (I can't see those on imageshack or stuff like that)

Here's mine...
It's an older picture I dug from July 2009 when I still had my Powershot..
Well, I still have it but don't use it...

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2702/4120677798_e3289a711f_b_d.jpg

I like it, too bad the left side is dark