d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Graphic Design > Photography > I Saw This And Thought All You Cannon Zealots > Would Vomit!
Prev123458Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 16,893
Joined: Aug 25 2005
Gold: 8,601.26
Nov 2 2010 11:37am
Quote (Antichrist- @ Nov 2 2010 01:24pm)
dof doesent work nothing like you said either.


Futurama is somewhat right. Same focal length at same aperture taken with a FF and a APS-C. The FF's DoF is thinner.
Member
Posts: 18,010
Joined: Apr 8 2008
Gold: 8,653.74
Nov 2 2010 11:45am
Nikon user:



Canon user:



YOU decide.

This post was edited by onepagememory on Nov 2 2010 11:46am
Member
Posts: 21,066
Joined: Dec 16 2005
Gold: 100.07
Nov 2 2010 11:59am



Lols.
Member
Posts: 6,029
Joined: Sep 23 2007
Gold: 0.00
Nov 2 2010 12:02pm
This topic is so win.. Haha...
Member
Posts: 29,057
Joined: Aug 3 2005
Gold: 13.37
Nov 2 2010 01:00pm
Quote (Eek @ 2 Nov 2010 20:37)
Futurama is somewhat right. Same focal length at same aperture taken with a FF and a APS-C. The FF's DoF is thinner.


thats because you have to move backwards to frame it the same way with same focal length on smaller sensor than on full frame. since the focus distance changes, the dof changes. its not about f-number, its about change in focus distance. if the distance is same, it makes the crop different, so if you crop the picture, but the crop factor of the smaller sensor, the dof will be the same. also when you focus closer(to frame same on larger sensor than on crop sensor) the focused area changes to blur faster, this is why full frame(, medium or large format) gives different type of dof to small sensors.
Member
Posts: 11,814
Joined: Feb 4 2006
Gold: 8.09
Nov 2 2010 02:07pm
Quote (Antichrist- @ Nov 2 2010 01:00pm)
thats because you have to move backwards to frame it the same way with same focal length on smaller sensor than on full frame. since the focus distance changes, the dof changes. its not about f-number, its about change in focus distance. if the distance is same, it makes the crop different, so if you crop the picture, but the crop factor of the smaller sensor, the dof will be the same. also when you focus closer(to frame same on larger sensor than on crop sensor) the focused area changes to blur faster, this is why full frame(, medium or large format) gives different type of dof to small sensors.


Well according to the reviews on the Olympus Zuiko 14-35 f2.0 the DOF created by a similar f2.8 zoom on a 35mm camera is still shallower.
I am sure there are numbers and comparison out there but I couldn't find it :(
but what you said kind of make sense :p
so I guess it means in order to get the same DOF as a larger sensor camera the smaller sensor has to use either a larger aperture or shorter focal length or a combination of both to achieve the same DOF. Right?
ffs this gives me headache :D

This post was edited by Futurama on Nov 2 2010 02:11pm
Member
Posts: 29,057
Joined: Aug 3 2005
Gold: 13.37
Nov 2 2010 02:16pm
Quote (Futurama @ 2 Nov 2010 23:07)
so I guess it means in order to get the same DOF as a larger sensor camera the smaller sensor has to use either a larger aperture or shorter focal length or a combination of both to achieve the same DOF. Right?
ffs this gives me headache :D


yes, but the dof will still look different. and with larger sensor you need to use longer focal length to get the same fov, longer focal length causes the focused area to turn to deeper bokeh faster
Member
Posts: 11,814
Joined: Feb 4 2006
Gold: 8.09
Nov 2 2010 02:54pm
Quote (Antichrist- @ Nov 2 2010 02:16pm)
yes, but the dof will still look different. and with larger sensor you need to use longer focal length to get the same fov, longer focal length causes the focused area to turn to deeper bokeh faster


hmm do you mean that longer focal length causes the focused area to shrink because focal length, aperture and distance to the focused subject are the main factors. The longer focal length the shallower the DOF would be and
the closer to the subject the shallower the DOF would be as well so it means if you want to get the same FOV with a 35mm sensor you would either use a longer focal length or get closer to the subject which means the DOF would
be shallower. Right?
Well at least that's what I have learned so far and other than that a 35mm camera also seems to be much better for landscape photography as well
which is why I just ordered a brand new 5D mk2 about five minutes ago :D Now all I have to do is wait..... :unsure:

This post was edited by Futurama on Nov 2 2010 02:54pm
Member
Posts: 16,893
Joined: Aug 25 2005
Gold: 8,601.26
Nov 2 2010 02:59pm
Quote (Futurama @ Nov 2 2010 04:54pm)
hmm do you mean that longer focal length causes the focused area to shrink because focal length, aperture and distance to the focused subject are the main factors. The longer focal length the shallower the DOF would be and
the closer to the subject the shallower the DOF would be as well so it means if you want to get the same FOV with a 35mm sensor you would either use a longer focal length or get closer to the subject which means the DOF would
be shallower. Right?
Well at least that's what I have learned so far and other than that a 35mm camera also seems to be much better for landscape photography as well
which is why I just ordered a brand new 5D mk2 about five minutes ago :DNow all I have to do is wait.....  :unsure:


ARGGHHHH



I'm sad now :(

But gratz anyway :lol:

This post was edited by Eek on Nov 2 2010 02:59pm
Member
Posts: 11,814
Joined: Feb 4 2006
Gold: 8.09
Nov 2 2010 03:03pm
Quote (Eek @ Nov 2 2010 02:59pm)
ARGGHHHH

http://actualplay.roleplayingpublicradio.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/fffuuu.jpg

I'm sad now :(

But gratz anyway :lol:


haha don't be sad. Unlike you I don't even have any lighting equipment all I have is some crappy 430EXII flash which I have only used like five times since I bought it :D
but thanks :D
Go Back To Photography Topic List
Prev123458Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll