d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Graphic Design > Photography > Which Program Actually Provides The True Color?
Prev12
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 47,715
Joined: Jul 29 2007
Gold: 487.42
Jul 13 2013 02:58pm
Quote (Canadian_Man @ Jul 13 2013 03:14pm)
Before posting this thread I already did :(


youre doing something wrong if every program displays a different color, you have to change it in both lightroom and ps
Member
Posts: 35,075
Joined: Jul 26 2006
Gold: 125.00
Jul 13 2013 03:27pm
Quote (Hermione @ Jul 13 2013 01:58pm)
youre doing something wrong if every program displays a different color, you have to change it in both lightroom and ps


No, only photoshop and lightroom display different colors (and Paint also displays the same color as lightroom & photoshop).

Windows image viewer & viewing the image online show an overall darker image. So when I edit, I tend to have to keep an image slightly lighter-looking in ps or lightroom in order to achieve the desired results when I show the image off.

I have a 27-inch LCD screen I picked up 2 years ago... I like it... it works nicely... but I'll be replacing it with an IPS in the future I guess.

This post was edited by Canadian_Man on Jul 13 2013 03:27pm
Member
Posts: 11,567
Joined: Sep 11 2008
Gold: 205.00
Jul 13 2013 11:57pm
Quote (Canadian_Man @ 14 Jul 2013 01:27)
No, only photoshop and lightroom display different colors (and Paint also displays the same color as lightroom & photoshop).

Windows image viewer & viewing the image online show an overall darker image. So when I edit, I tend to have to keep an image slightly lighter-looking in ps or lightroom in order to achieve the desired results when I show the image off.

I have a 27-inch LCD screen I picked up 2 years ago... I like it... it works nicely... but I'll be replacing it with an IPS in the future I guess.


I have a killer IPS screen, it is amazing, HOWEVER its not what I recommend 1st, calibration is way more important so 1st get a calibration tool you will see a vast improvement
you should always see a slight difference in PS/LR compared to on the net etc as PS/LR use AdobeRGB and the net can only handle sRGB
in LR/PS we use AdobeRGB as it covers more of the colour spectrum and therefore gives a truer representation, this is great for printing or viewing on PCs but when uploading to the web we need to export from PS/LR as sRGB, also a good idea to let PS/LR resize to the required size for the specific website and also reduce dpi to 96 (std web settings)
PS/LR does a much better job of the conversion and resizing than the web software
if this is done then the final exported image should be very similar in all applications etc

oh and remember to export 2 images
one for web (jpeg) and 1high quality, can depend on how or who prints your photos, but something like tiff 300dpi etc
Member
Posts: 14,659
Joined: Jan 27 2007
Gold: 78.16
Jul 14 2013 04:25am
Quote (AXIS @ Jul 14 2013 05:23am)
I wouldnt think monitor calibration would be an issue considering you are looking at the same image on the same monitor, just in different areas.
I have noticed the issue on my monitor sometimes as well (mainly on images where I bump up the vibrance. It looks good in PS and a bit too vibrant when posted online)


Hardware calibration implements a standard profile across your whole system.

Quote (Canadian_Man @ Jul 14 2013 07:27am)
No, only photoshop and lightroom display different colors (and Paint also displays the same color as lightroom & photoshop).

Windows image viewer & viewing the image online show an overall darker image. So when I edit, I tend to have to keep an image slightly lighter-looking in ps or lightroom in order to achieve the desired results when I show the image off.

I have a 27-inch LCD screen I picked up 2 years ago... I like it... it works nicely... but I'll be replacing it with an IPS in the future I guess.


The way windows does it is funny... You have to set your windows viewing profile to the same profile PS/LR use. If you hardware calibrate this is automatic.

right click desktop > screen resolution > advanced settings > colour management > colour management > "profiles associated with this device"

What is the name of the profile listed?



Go Back To Photography Topic List
Prev12
Add Reply New Topic New Poll