#1 woulda won contest.

first shot is great. and yeah, it´s a good lens. prolly the best ultra wide angle lens for crop. I´m still waiting for mine to get back from the tokina support. Sent it to them like 3 weeks ago because the lens hood didnt fit correctly..............sucks

The first one is just great :D.

Ranking:
1
3
2
5
4
6

Or something like that

Thanks everybody for the feedback!



Thanks mate, I will surely do that as soon as possible
Still I think I could have done a little better, that pic is a bit offset to the right and maybe not perfectly horizontal. There's always room for improvement!


I'd like to add a note about the Tokina. This is a 100% crop of the top right corner of a picture.
Now tell me it's not sharp



11 mm
f/11
1/3 second



This post was edited by AlPi on Nov 7 2010 10:19am

This is the picture I took the crop from:



11 mm
f/16
0.6 seconds

It's somewhat sharp, although I've seen sharper. Your shutter speed had a lot to do with it.

You mean sharper for a tokina or in general?

Remeber it's an extremely wide lens and corners are usually the less sharp parts.

I don't own a wide-angle lens, but a female photographer I work with has this insanely sharp Tokina as well. I was like wtf? when I saw it. Did you post edit the distortion on the edges? On a second look, it does look rather sharp.

Which reminds me, last night I shot in about 20% sunset with iso 2600. Awesome quality images. I love the 5dmk II

The cropped image is absolutely untouched, straight from camera.

I've corrected the distortion only on the full image I took the crop from.

Every picture in post #1 is NOT corrected tho.

I'm using PTlens to correct the distortion and I still don't know if it does a good job. I couldn't say there's disortion in any picture, probably I need more straight lines in a pic to notice it.

Also, the Tokina 11-16 is for cropped sensors only, you can't mount it on a 5D mk II