I like the first picture!
It has a quite scary atmosphere and the fence is making it even more scary. I like you made it b/w it gives more power to te atmosphere.

the first two are nice but the last one is boring - try to get more of the tree and surroundings in the frame.

now that i look at it again i really like the first, even though im not a big fan of b&w digital photography

The first 1 is rly good

can you zoom out any more than that?

if yes you might have a good picture there!
if no, its only slightly better than the first

Well. I am not trying to be rude, but I think you have misread it. You need to catch some of the background.

Hmm sadly I dont think I can zoom out on that. But this will give an idea of the background with the same trees at least a little:

They all look kinda depressing. Did you desaturated those pictures in photoshop or you used in-camera b&w function?

that is a thousand times more interesting

nice one!


heres somthing to try if you really like the depressed mood: take a colour picture then lower the saturation on it, this will drain the colour, but is a nice effect - dont over do it or the colours will look really washed out.