I was thinking if we make a sticky that specifies good rares it’ll cut down a lot of random rare post and give people an idea of what to look for in rares. I feel like this would benefit a lot of groups including the trophy room group. I know there’s a wide range of what people look for in rares but here’s some suggestions.

Ammys -

Must:
2+ All skills
10%fcr+

Must have one:
Str
Dex
Resist

Bonus:
Life
Mana

Fools claw -

Must:
20%ias+
250%+ Ed
Fools mod
Eth

Must have one:
2+ assa
3+ LS
2 socket

Bonus:
Self repair

Or something along these lines ( I suck at examples lol) It’s just a suggestion and figured it could help a lot of new people and OGs out.

you forget people do not read stickies

evidence, posting in the wrong forum... sticked
use a Mediator to not get scammed... sticked
general help answers.... stickied

just a waste of time an effort

Yeah that’s the only downfall but I feel people might read that because in some eyes they’ll see what items to look for to get more fg ?

It's debatable what is "must have", which is one reason why such list doesn't exist.
A listing of all maximum possible stats would be more helpful.

People use trophy room to pricecheck their items. That's why they constantly post crap there.
Then they cry that people are rude to them. I doubt that ever changes.

That’s what I’m saying this will cut a lot of those people out of the trophy room. They can look at this list and if their item doesn't meet the basic requirements of good rare item then they’ll know.

Yea except every thing is subjective when it comes to what items the individual believes are trophies. Especially in a game with drops like d2. Here the standard is high. So even if it's not a trophy to us. To someone else it's one of the best things they have found. Back on non ladder they had a price check sticky not for every rare or every drop but a lot of things made the list. People still posted for price checks besides going to the sticky. The same will happen here. We get a big ol list filled with ideal stats on ideal rare items. People will still post threads asking about the items they find.

What do you think could be done different from the non ladder one if a new one was made ? Or do you think it’s just inevitable ? If everybody shared the URL on all the bad rare post then that person might share it on the next one they see ? I know there will still be some but you don’t think this will eliminate alot of it ?

I sadly think it's inevitable.