d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > General Help > Site Suggestions >
Poll > More Than 4 Threads Up In The Top 50 Notification
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 77,675
Joined: May 19 2003
Gold: 3,614.04
Nov 25 2021 06:18pm
Good day, everyone!

As we all know, there is a trading rule that says "Do not have more than 4 threads up in the top 50 at any time."

Sometimes, when you are bumping a lot of trading topics, you need to manually count, how many of them are right now in top 50. I am using "ctrl + F" with my name, to monitor the quantity of my own topics in the top, and I can say, this can be a little bit annoying.

This is even more actual for Legacy Diablo 2 trading sections, as they are having not that much active users right now, and quite slow topic rotation.

Maybe we should add an automatic notifier, which will appear for the user who have 4 or more active trading topics in top 50?
It could looks something like this:


What do you guys think, can this be useful?

Kind regards,
snoop3r
Member
Posts: 8,489
Joined: Apr 6 2009
Gold: 0.00
Nov 25 2021 06:52pm
Vote Yes. There are many rules to remember, if sometimes you can have a « warning » notification before doing something wrong, I think this can help.
Thanks snoop.
Member
Posts: 10,197
Joined: Aug 12 2006
Gold: 44,675.01
Trader: Trusted
Nov 25 2021 06:58pm
Voted no since you could just make 1topic with multi items ..
Member
Posts: 77,675
Joined: May 19 2003
Gold: 3,614.04
Dec 7 2021 11:57am
Quote (Vinc3nt @ 26 Nov 2021 03:52)
Vote Yes. There are many rules to remember, if sometimes you can have a « warning » notification before doing something wrong, I think this can help.
Thanks snoop.


Thank you for your opinion :)

Quote (archangel_of_heaven @ 26 Nov 2021 03:58)
Voted no since you could just make 1topic with multi items ..


Thank you for opinion, but I am not suggesting to increase the number of allowed trade topics in top50, just offering an opportunity to give a notice for users who are close to have more than 4 topics in top-50, for some reason (those can be not only Ft topics, but also Iso) :)

Member
Posts: 3,987
Joined: Jun 18 2010
Gold: 7,651.00
Dec 7 2021 12:10pm
Problem is you can't always control it, some people bump your "old" sales or bid on auction.

And honestly i belive most people respect that rule most of the time
Member
Posts: 28,348
Joined: Mar 13 2006
Gold: 450.00
Trader: Trusted
Dec 7 2021 12:10pm
Voting no simply because some sub forums are so dead it would be impossible to avoid this rule, and there are exceptions.

For example: https://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=48
If you had 4 topics here you would have to wait 20+ days before the automated system would allow you to make a new post.

Another example: https://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=55
You would have to wait 4 months.

This post was edited by Josha on Dec 7 2021 12:13pm
Member
Posts: 77,675
Joined: May 19 2003
Gold: 3,614.04
Dec 7 2021 01:45pm
Was not talking about any kind of automatic restriction, only about some kind of notification :)
Anyway, thank you for your opinion.
Member
Posts: 19,547
Joined: Mar 27 2017
Gold: 8,623.95
Dec 7 2021 09:44pm
Quote (archangel_of_heaven @ Nov 25 2021 06:58pm)
Voted no since you could just make 1topic with multi items ..



I would agree with this, if your in a sub forum that’s slow like the ones Josha posted you would wanna put all iso or ft in 1 post since it’s gonna be on the front page for awhile.
Member
Posts: 61,030
Joined: May 29 2006
Gold: 25,003.31
Dec 8 2021 12:31am
What’s the point of this. You think people with 4 in the top 50 don’t already know? They simply don’t care
Retired Moderator
Posts: 6,662
Joined: Oct 3 2021
Gold: 61,913.30
Trader: Trusted
Dec 8 2021 03:23pm
Quote (snoop3r @ Nov 25 2021 04:18pm)
Good day, everyone!

As we all know, there is a trading rule that says "Do not have more than 4 threads up in the top 50 at any time."

Sometimes, when you are bumping a lot of trading topics, you need to manually count, how many of them are right now in top 50. I am using "ctrl + F" with my name, to monitor the quantity of my own topics in the top, and I can say, this can be a little bit annoying.

This is even more actual for Legacy Diablo 2 trading sections, as they are having not that much active users right now, and quite slow topic rotation.

Maybe we should add an automatic notifier, which will appear for the user who have 4 or more active trading topics in top 50?
It could looks something like this:
https://i.imgur.com/IeaV8QM.png

What do you guys think, can this be useful?

Kind regards,
snoop3r


Hey Snoop3r,

Overall, I like the idea. I think more information is always better than less. Especially for new members who are not often aware of this rule. If the implementation of this idea is not too involving - then why not.

Even if it is a little bit redundant as some people suggest, I believe it can be a helpful notification for some people.

Voted yes :)
Go Back To Site Suggestions Topic List
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll