Old topic messed up with graphical presentation and after talking to staff member, I was suggested to create new topic with updated information.
Suggestion is to make it possible to choose which tabs are visible on Guild page. Some of the tabs contain no useful information for most, like Trade Rank or Group if there are no Scammer tagged or Meditator/Trusted people on this list. It would make a lot cleaner overall look.
For example, I don't want to have ranks for my guild members for reasons, hence it would be nice to be able remove that tab completely instead of just playing with invisible characters to create blank ranks and still have that empty tab cluttering page.
In previous thread there were few opinions posted which I quote here. Some of the opinions are valid and all but keep in mind it does not just affect Ranks tab. Guild Owner or other user with granted permissions could hide or show any tab on the Members List.
I personally would only have Last Seen tab visible from all of them. Personal taste of course but why not give this option to users if it is possible to implement.
Votes in previous thread were 3 for Yes, 3 for No and 1 for Perhaps with some modification (without posting what modification it would need). This time I go with two voting options only and if you are torn between the two, post your suggestion without voting or null your vote.
Hope you like my idea and thank you for reading!
***
From old thread:Quote (LindeRKV @ 1 Jun 2018 15:59)
Quote (Phyerox @ 1 Jun 2018 15:05)
Just speculating here but I believe most guilds use their ranks, so that is probably why there has not been any interest in this.
To be 100% honest yours is the first guild I have ever seen without ranks. I can see how this would make the guild page cleaner for those who don't use ranks, but again, from what I have seen it's not many. :p
I'll hold off on voting for now to see what others think.
Yes, of course. Disabling Ranks tab was just a part and example of whole suggestion. I am suggesting that you could set any tab on Member List to show/hide.Quote (LindeRKV @ 2 Jun 2018 17:23)
Quote (beacon @ 2 Jun 2018 17:07)
Not necessarily a bad idea, but I guess I'm just trying to figure out why you'd want to hide some of these fields? None of the fields seem irrelevant to me, really.
I mean, I guess Guild Points are redundant to someone who aren't interested in Ladder Slasher, but I've never looked at a roster and wanted to hide any particular tab, personally.
For myself, I don't see the point of having Group, Warn, Trade Rank nor Joined tabs there. I don't personally care about warn % of my guild members and don't have any of the mods or trusted/meditator people there so it just clutters the page.
Personally I would only have Last Seen tab visible since it is only one that provides any useful information.
Guess it is matter of taste/choice but my suggestion is to give ability to choose to guild owners.
Thanks!Quote (LindeRKV @ 2 Jul 2018 11:53)
Quote (Cel @ 2 Jul 2018 10:25)
Voted no because of the following reason:
You could give guild members ranks which are racist/discriminating or whatever. While they are not able to see it because they simply don’t have the permission to change rank settings or because you removed the column for ranks with your suggestion.
Also if you uncheck all options the entire guild list would be completely empty and would look like an unfinished lackluster.
If no one can see this discriminating rank then why is it important? It is basically same as insulting someone in thoughts.
I would say judgement on looks is subjective and would be nice to have choice to modify it to what looks good in my eyes. Instead of having page full of lackcluster of unimportant content what it is right now.
I value your opinion and second point is pretty valid but still subjective. If this site would update by that mentality, we would have no orbs, themes or anything.
Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.