"What should a good Site Suggestion contain?"

should be

"What is required for a Site Suggestion."


Can't tell if its a "good" one or mandatory.
What do you guys think?

This post was edited by simpleforce on Aug 21 2013 08:23pm

Please read this: http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=57896631&f=258
"How to post a site suggestion"
Its fine imho.
And you need a poll in suggestions.

Maybe someone with technical writing skills should edit these peoples sentences. No one knows whose behind that screen. Could have been made by a 12 year old or someone who whipped up something in 12 seconds.

Well this is the way I see it:


You can be as vague as you want, without the use of any arguments or a poll, and pictures are not a must for a lot of things
However your layout won't be as good or "efficient" as it would be if you do include all of those things
If you don't use a poll, you won't have a visual representation of what people voted for, you'd just have a myriad of posts
If you posted something vague and then later thought of adding more details, they will most likely not be seen by a lot of people as most people do not read through posts, only relying on the first post
So no, its not mandatory, but it would be better and considered a "good" suggestion if you have all of that in your post