Would be cool if you could make it so you could share a type of guild chat for this reason:

Alot of guilds like to get together and do 4 v 4 guild duels on d2

anyways, this would be a cool thing so that we can keep track of whose winning and not, i know the topic tracker is available but that doesnt last long enough.

Yes but there is also legit dueling for that reason (the sub forum on here)

yea but that forum sux, soo many modders post s/s of people dieing and crap, people get soo big on that.

No, I want guild chats to stay private

reason it should be optional, what i mean is like if guilds agree to this like when people request to add u or w/e u have to accept, i think it should be something like this.

http://forums.d2jsp.org/events.php

Make a event and select "Require Approval Before Join".