d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > General Help > Site Suggestions >
Poll > New Report Button? > Yes / No - Gimme Your Opinion Please!
12321Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 60,726
Joined: May 6 2009
Gold: 590.33
Jul 11 2012 08:58am
Hello jsp!
I've posted this before, but lost track of the topic.

And here is why I post this:
I've noticed that many users are posting multiple topics to bypass early bump rule.
Many of them don't know it themself I think.

*Updating ISO/FT-list with a new Thread - Isn't this early bump?
*Posting several threads about the same trade - Clearly early bump


When reporting these two issues as "Early bump" does not work, it seems.
Allready went 24 hours since I reported 3 topics, I pm'ed 2 mods as the first one didn't close them, and also no reply for 24 hours.
But the topics are still open and he keeps early bumpin....

Time to add this button?
"Multiple topics"


Would appreciate some opinions.
Regards Stuk3hu
Member
Posts: 9,835
Joined: Mar 18 2008
Gold: 1,279.00
Jul 11 2012 09:35am
Quote (Stuk3hu @ Jul 12 2012 12:58am)
Hello jsp!
I've posted this before, but lost track of the topic.

And here is why I post this:
I've noticed that many users are posting multiple topics to bypass early bump rule.
Many of them don't know it themself I think.

*Updating ISO/FT-list with a new Thread - Isn't this early bump?
*Posting several threads about the same trade - Clearly early bump


When reporting these two issues as "Early bump" does not work, it seems.
Allready went 24 hours since I reported 3 topics, I pm'ed 2 mods as the first one didn't close them, and also no reply for 24 hours.
But the topics are still open and he keeps early bumpin....

Time to add this button?
"Multiple topics"
http://img52.imageshack.us/img52/4264/95965320.png

Would appreciate some opinions.
Regards Stuk3hu


they early bump and avoid the "too many posts in top 50" rule/report too

This post was edited by bahupurass on Jul 11 2012 09:44am
Member
Posts: 60,726
Joined: May 6 2009
Gold: 590.33
Jul 12 2012 01:38pm
Quote (bahupurass @ 11 Jul 2012 15:35)
they early bump and avoid the "too many posts in top 50" rule/report too


Yeah, I know.
But this is only a suggestion to add this Multiple topics-button.
As "Too many topics in top 50" allready is there.

:)

Quote (Hylia @ 12 Jul 2012 19:40)
It enters in early bump I believe. I'll hold my vote for now.

Well, the only problem then is that: When you report these kind of posts as early bump, they won't get closed.
Because mods will search for Early bumps in each Individual topic that got reported for Early bump!


And guys:
THIS IS NOT ABOUT ADDING ANY RULES! THE RULE IS THERE ALLREADY!
Quote
Early Bump:
    Creating several threads to bypass the early bump rule.


This post was edited by Stuk3hu on Jul 12 2012 01:58pm
Member
Posts: 13,294
Joined: Jul 30 2011
Gold: 10.00
Jul 12 2012 01:40pm
It enters in early bump I believe. I'll hold my vote for now.
Member
Posts: 24,688
Joined: Jul 10 2008
Gold: 0.01
Warn: 10%
Jul 12 2012 02:01pm
If i remember correct, this was suggested before.

And users were talking aldo about adding a "notebox" so you could add links to it about other topics. And also explain, if you report something else.
But i cant remember how it turned then.
Imho its easyer to just go to users profile, when you see him/her having multiple topics, gather links and send to TA or TM.
Nulling this. I cant deside if its needed or not. :)
Member
Posts: 15,607
Joined: Oct 9 2009
Gold: 0.00
Jul 12 2012 02:07pm
[x] No

You say you reported three topics due to early bumping its not early bump, its a top 50 violation. If you were able to report each topic for early bump it's saying they're posting within a four hour span, that says they have too many in the top 50 so you report each first post with the top 50 violation.

Here: http://forums.d2jsp.org/info.php?p=6

Quote (Stuk3hu @ Jul 11 2012 08:58am)
Top 50?

Having 2 topics of the same thread is not top 50 violation!
It is early bump if you're bumping both the topics within 4 hours (2 hour-bump).
But reporting as Early bump does not work, so adding: Multiple topics-button  is helpfull.
Allready went 24 hours sinceI reported 3 topics, I pm'ed 2 mods as the first one didn't close them, and also no reply for 24 hours.
But the topics are still open and he keeps early bumpin....





Well since you do say you reported three topics by the same person this means they are posting three topics back to back to bypass the early bump rule but it's violating the top 50 rule because you only can have two topics in the top 50. Thanks for your inquiry via pm, as it turns out yes I do speak English. :)

This post was edited by heyajsp on Jul 12 2012 02:29pm
Member
Posts: 60,726
Joined: May 6 2009
Gold: 590.33
Jul 12 2012 02:10pm
Quote (A2K @ 12 Jul 2012 20:01)
If i remember correct, this was suggested before.

And users were talking aldo about adding a "notebox" so you could add links to it about other topics. And also explain, if you report something else.
But i cant remember how it turned then.
Imho its easyer to just go to users profile, when you see him/her having multiple topics, gather links and send to TA or TM.
Nulling this. I cant deside if its needed or not. :)


Ehm... Who is it that keeps this forum clean?
Random members, or those who are lucky enough to get Tagged(Trusted/Medi/Member+/Admin).

I don't know how it looks like for the reported threads, but if it's reported as early bump, and he clearly does not have any early bumps in THAT thread.
Then you should be able to do that yourself. Go profile, last posts/topics - and pick out the early bumps to close them.

Quote (heyajsp @ 12 Jul 2012 20:07)
[x] No

You say you reported three topics due to early bumping its not early bump, its a top 50 violation. If you were able to report each topic for early bump it's saying they're posting within a four hour span, that says they have too many in the top 50 so you report each first post with the top 50 violation.

Here: http://forums.d2jsp.org/info.php?p=6

Well since you do say you reported three topics by the same person this means they are posting three topics back to back to bypass the early bump rule but it's violating the top 50 rule because you only can have two topics in the top 50. Thanks for your inquiry via pm, as it turns out yes I do speak English. :)

THIS HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THE TOP 50!
And why the hell did you block me? "Don't bother replying n this" :Rofl: Don't bother posting off-topics, and vote before you're done reading the matter!
Message to the people:
DO NOT VOTE BEFORE YOU'VE READ EVERYTHING!
Thanks!


Having 2 topics of the same thread is not top 50 violation!
However, having more than 2 topics in top 50 topics, is "top 50 violation".
But this has nothing to do with Top 50!

Quote (A2K @ 12 Jul 2012 20:01)
If i remember correct, this was suggested before.

And users were talking aldo about adding a "notebox" so you could add links to it about other topics. And also explain, if you report something else.
But i cant remember how it turned then.
Imho its easyer to just go to users profile, when you see him/her having multiple topics, gather links and send to TA or TM.
Nulling this. I cant deside if its needed or not. :)

Well, read this please. I've been countering several early bump-issues like this. The topic has NOT been closed when reporting as Early bump!
It is early bump if you're bumping both the topics within 4 hours (2 hour-bump).
But reporting as Early bump does not work, so adding: Multiple topics-button is helpfull.

This post was edited by Stuk3hu on Jul 12 2012 02:33pm
Member
Posts: 24,688
Joined: Jul 10 2008
Gold: 0.01
Warn: 10%
Jul 12 2012 02:37pm
Bypassing early bump rule: creating multiple topics about same iso/ft/pc (2 or more)
I give yes for adding button for it, after having a PM conversation with topics creator.
Member
Posts: 60,726
Joined: May 6 2009
Gold: 590.33
Jul 12 2012 04:18pm
Quote (A2K @ 12 Jul 2012 20:37)
Bypassing early bump rule: creating multiple topics about same iso/ft/pc (2 or more)
I give yes for adding button for it, after having a PM conversation with topics creator.


Yeah, thanks for a short, good explanation of what I meant with #1.
Adding this button would be very helpfull.

I also encountered a suggestion like you said about "Notebox" under the report-options so you could write the exact violation and then it would be very easy for mods to track it down and deal with it.
:)

Something like this maybe?


This post was edited by Stuk3hu on Jul 12 2012 04:20pm
Member
Posts: 60,726
Joined: May 6 2009
Gold: 590.33
Jul 13 2012 10:50pm
**

Opinions please :)
Go Back To Site Suggestions Topic List
12321Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll