d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > General Help > Site Suggestions >
Poll > ** Guild Alliances! Renewed! ** > With A Guest Appearence From: Titan !
Prev17891011142Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Trade Moderator
Posts: 39,040
Joined: Apr 4 2007
Gold: 146,764.22
Trader: Mediator
Mar 15 2010 10:06am
Quote (Heid @ Feb 24 2010 01:24pm)
just something else that can be taken advantage of
i would share gear with other elite guilds and make them even more powerhouses
i would probably use it and love it
but i think the idea is imbalanced


this, sorry don't see it happening. At least the shared vault
Retired Moderator
Posts: 26,811
Joined: Mar 12 2007
Gold: 1,338.21
Trader: Trusted
Mar 15 2010 10:21am
No.

I'll explain my reasons:

Every guild is meant to be a group of friends / persons with the same goal; if a certain amount of persons feel well together they should make theirs own guild.
Where's the fun of "Guild Only" games if in fact you are 2 guilds playing together and not only one?
Shared Vault might be dangerous, people complaining of scams and such problems in example.
Guild topics can be already public, I can buy a topic and call it "Ancients and 1337 guilds Topic" and put the rule inside asking to don't post if you are not in any of those guilds.

Just my 2 cents
Member
Posts: 39,152
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 9,070.07
Mar 16 2010 01:46am
Quote (NewStyle @ Mar 15 2010 11:21am)
No.

I'll explain my reasons:

Every guild is meant to be a group of friends / persons with the same goal; if a certain amount of persons feel well together they should make theirs own guild.
Where's the fun of "Guild Only" games if in fact you are 2 guilds playing together and not only one?
Shared Vault might be dangerous, people complaining of scams and such problems in example.
Guild topics can be already public, I can buy a topic and call it "Ancients and 1337 guilds Topic" and put the rule inside asking to don't post if you are not in any of those guilds.

Just my 2 cents


Yeah it's a good point, but some people want to have their own guilds... but have a really good friend leading another guild, etc.
So it would be nice for them to be able to do this type of stuff, you know?
But I see what you are saying.

Quote (Moojilsuh @ Mar 15 2010 11:06am)
this, sorry don't see it happening. At least the shared vault


you should of read a few pages at least... we went over it.
Member
Posts: 10,852
Joined: Aug 10 2008
Gold: 1.94
Mar 16 2010 01:49am
I like the idea but overall kinda expensive imo :P
Member
Posts: 39,152
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 9,070.07
Mar 17 2010 06:55am
Quote (wickedjdr @ Mar 16 2010 02:49am)
I like the idea but overall kinda expensive imo :P


That's the price for great things! ^_^
Member
Posts: 36,249
Joined: Feb 10 2008
Gold: 4,377.00
Trader: Trusted
Mar 17 2010 08:09am
i wouldn't use it personally, but it sounds extremely useful for slashers
i see this being used, definitely

edit:
yes

edit2:
Quote (NewStyle @ Mar 15 2010 11:21am)
No.

I'll explain my reasons:

Every guild is meant to be a group of friends / persons with the same goal; if a certain amount of persons feel well together they should make theirs own guild.
Where's the fun of "Guild Only" games if in fact you are 2 guilds playing together and not only one?
Shared Vault might be dangerous, people complaining of scams and such problems in example.
Guild topics can be already public, I can buy a topic and call it "Ancients and 1337 guilds Topic" and put the rule inside asking to don't post if you are not in any of those guilds.

Just my 2 cents


well, that's your vision of things, but as shown in this topic, not everyone shares it
if you don't like alliance, like you just said, nobody obligates you to make/accept one
just keep it to your guild and your guild only ^^

edit3:
and shared vaults are dangerous anywhere, if you accept someone into your guild with bad intentions, put something in the vault, there's still a possibility he runs away with it
i totally agree on the guild topic side though

edit4:
i think it's a decent idea if worked out well
i don't see this happening though, at least not anytime soon

This post was edited by Gwarr on Mar 17 2010 08:14am
Member
Posts: 25,531
Joined: May 8 2007
Gold: 3,720.00
Mar 17 2010 08:12am
wow just read this and I LOVE IT!!!!

[x] YESSSSS
Member
Posts: 39,152
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 9,070.07
Mar 17 2010 11:04am
Quote (MotherOfTwo @ Mar 17 2010 09:12am)
wow just read this and I LOVE IT!!!!

[x] YESSSSS


tyvm Marie! :wub:

Quote (Gwarr @ Mar 17 2010 09:09am)
i wouldn't use it personally, but it sounds extremely useful for slashers
i see this being used, definitely

edit:
yes

edit2:


well, that's your vision of things, but as shown in this topic, not everyone shares it
if you don't like alliance, like you just said, nobody obligates you to make/accept one
just keep it to your guild and your guild only ^^

edit3:
and shared vaults are dangerous anywhere, if you accept someone into your guild with bad intentions, put something in the vault, there's still a possibility he runs away with it
i totally agree on the guild topic side though

edit4:
i think it's a decent idea if worked out well
i don't see this happening though, at least not anytime soon


thanks nick, and yeah I see what you say/mean - good input
Banned
Posts: 7,233
Joined: Feb 26 2010
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 10%
Mar 17 2010 11:05am
sure
Member
Posts: 39,152
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 9,070.07
Mar 18 2010 07:17pm
Quote (ClaussDK @ Mar 17 2010 12:05pm)
sure


thanks for the support

Bump
Go Back To Site Suggestions Topic List
Prev17891011142Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll